Mike Wu,Sonali Parbhoo,Michael Hughes,Ryan Kindle,Leo Celi,Maurizio Zazzi,Volker Roth,Finale Doshi-Velez
Abstract:The lack of interpretability remains a barrier to the adoption of deep neural networks. Recently, tree regularization has been proposed to encourage deep neural networks to resemble compact, axis-aligned decision trees without significant compromises in accuracy. However, it may be unreasonable to expect that a single tree can predict well across all possible inputs. In this work, we propose regional tree regularization, which encourages a deep model to be well-approximated by several separate decision trees specific to predefined regions of the input space. Practitioners can define regions based on domain knowledge of contexts where different decision-making logic is needed. Across many datasets, our approach delivers more accurate predictions than simply training separate decision trees for each region, while producing simpler explanations than other neural net regularization schemes without sacrificing predictive power. Two healthcare case studies in critical care and HIV demonstrate how experts can improve understanding of deep models via our approach.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of interpretability of deep neural networks in many key security fields (such as healthcare). Specifically, the author points out that although deep neural networks perform well in many applications, their black - box nature makes it difficult to understand the prediction logic of the model, thus limiting the application of these models in fields that require a high level of trust and interpretability.
To solve this problem, the paper proposes a new regularization method - **Regional Tree Regularization**. Traditional methods usually rely on global or local explanations, but these methods have their own limitations:
- **Global Explanation**: It attempts to use a simple global model to explain the behavior of the entire neural network. However, such a simple model often fails to accurately capture the nuances of complex data distributions, resulting in inaccurate explanations.
- **Local Explanation**: It provides local explanations for each input point. Although it can better capture local patterns, it is difficult to generalize to other input points and lacks overall consistency.
In contrast, Regional Tree Regularization achieves a more flexible and interpretable model by dividing the input space into multiple predefined regions and requiring that the decision logic within each region can be approximated by a simple decision tree. This method not only maintains the accuracy of the model but also provides explanations that are easy for humans to understand.
### Specific Problems and Solutions
1. **Limitations of Global Explanation**:
- **Problem**: A single global decision tree is difficult to perform well on all inputs, which may lead to an optimal solution that is neither interpretable nor has good performance.
- **Solution**: Introduce Regional Tree Regularization, allowing different regions to have different decision trees, thereby improving interpretability and accuracy.
2. **Limitations of Local Explanation**:
- **Problem**: Local explanations are difficult to generalize to adjacent inputs, which may lead to false assumptions about generalization.
- **Solution**: Through region division, ensure that there is a simple and consistent explanation within each region, avoiding the limitations of local explanations.
3. **Optimization Challenges**:
- **Problem**: Traditional global tree regularization methods face computational difficulties during optimization, especially when the decision tree training process is non - differentiable.
- **Solution**: Introduce new regularization terms and technological innovations (such as using SparseMax penalty, data augmentation, Deterministic CART, etc.) to improve the stability and efficiency of optimization.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
- **Propose the Regional Tree Regularization Method**: By dividing the input space into multiple regions and training a simple decision tree for each region, a more flexible and interpretable deep - learning model is achieved.
- **Solve the Optimization Problem**: Develop multiple technological innovations, including using SparseMax penalty, data augmentation, and Deterministic CART, to ensure the stability and effectiveness of the optimization process.
- **Experimental Verification**: Experiments on multiple datasets (including two medical applications) prove that this method can provide simpler and interpretable decision logic while maintaining high accuracy.
In summary, this paper aims to solve the problem of insufficient interpretability of deep neural networks in key security fields by introducing the Regional Tree Regularization method, thereby promoting the wide adoption of these models in practical applications.