Abstract:Classic results establish that encouraging predictive diversity improves performance in ensembles of low-capacity models, e.g. through bagging or boosting. Here we demonstrate that these intuitions do not apply to high-capacity neural network ensembles (deep ensembles), and in fact the opposite is often true. In a large scale study of nearly 600 neural network classification ensembles, we examine a variety of interventions that trade off component model performance for predictive diversity. While such interventions can improve the performance of small neural network ensembles (in line with standard intuitions), they harm the performance of the large neural network ensembles most often used in practice. Surprisingly, we also find that discouraging predictive diversity is often benign in large-network ensembles, fully inverting standard intuitions. Even when diversity-promoting interventions do not sacrifice component model performance (e.g. using heterogeneous architectures and training paradigms), we observe an opportunity cost associated with pursuing increased predictive diversity. Examining over 1000 ensembles, we observe that the performance benefits of diverse architectures/training procedures are easily dwarfed by the benefits of simply using higher-capacity models, despite the fact that such higher capacity models often yield significantly less predictive diversity. Overall, our findings demonstrate that standard intuitions around predictive diversity, originally developed for low-capacity ensembles, do not directly apply to modern high-capacity deep ensembles. This work clarifies fundamental challenges to the goal of improving deep ensembles by making them more diverse, while suggesting an alternative path: simply forming ensembles from ever more powerful (and less diverse) component models.

Deep ensemble network with explicit complementary model for accuracy-balanced classification

Deep Negative Correlation Classification

Harmony Loss for Unbalanced Prediction

Deep Neural Network Ensembles against Deception: Ensemble Diversity, Accuracy and Robustness

An Adaptive Multi-Class Imbalanced Classification Framework Based on Ensemble Methods and Deep Network

Deep Super Learner: A Deep Ensemble for Classification Problems

Deep Ensemble Collaborative Learning by using Knowledge-transfer Graph for Fine-grained Object Classification

Improving Deep Neural Network Ensembles Using Reconstruction Error

MEAL: Multi-Model Ensemble via Adversarial Learning

A Study of Ensemble of Hybrid Networks with Strong Regularization

Pathologies of Predictive Diversity in Deep Ensembles

Revisiting Ensembles in an Adversarial Context: Improving Natural Accuracy

Deep Ensembles: A Loss Landscape Perspective

The relative performance of ensemble methods with deep convolutional neural networks for image classification

Towards Understanding Ensemble, Knowledge Distillation and Self-Distillation in Deep Learning

Efficient Diversity-Driven Ensemble for Deep Neural Networks

Class-Imbalanced Deep Learning via a Class-Balanced Ensemble

A hybrid ensemble method with negative correlation learning for regression

Teacher outputs Student outputs Teacher ? Student ? ! ! " !

Deep InterBoost networks for small-sample image classification

Deep Neural Network Confidence Calibration from Stochastic Weight Averaging