Adaptive Susceptibility and Heterogeneity in Contagion Models on Networks

Renato Pagliara,Naomi E. Leonard
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1907.08829
2020-04-12
Abstract:Contagious processes, such as spread of infectious diseases, social behaviors, or computer viruses, affect biological, social, and technological systems. Epidemic models for large populations and finite populations on networks have been used to understand and control both transient and steady-state behaviors. Typically it is assumed that after recovery from an infection, every agent will either return to its original susceptible state or acquire full immunity to reinfection. We study the network SIRI (Susceptible-Infected-Recovered-Infected) model, an epidemic model for the spread of contagious processes on a network of heterogeneous agents that can adapt their susceptibility to reinfection. The model generalizes existing models to accommodate realistic conditions in which agents acquire partial or compromised immunity after first exposure to an infection. We prove necessary and sufficient conditions on model parameters and network structure that distinguish four dynamic regimes: infection-free, epidemic, endemic, and bistable. For the bistable regime, which is not accounted for in traditional models, we show how there can be a rapid resurgent epidemic after what looks like convergence to an infection-free population. We use the model and its predictive capability to show how control strategies can be designed to mitigate problematic contagious behaviors.
Optimization and Control,Social and Information Networks,Dynamical Systems,Physics and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to study the adaptive susceptibility and heterogeneity of contagion processes in networks, especially for the network SIRI (Susceptible - Infected - Recovered - Infected) model. Specifically, the paper attempts to solve the following key problems: 1. **Limitations of existing models**: - Existing SIS (Susceptible - Infected - Susceptible) and SIR (Susceptible - Infected - Recovered) models assume that individuals either recover to their original susceptible state after being infected or acquire full immunity. These models cannot explain more complex immune situations in the real world, such as partial immunity or impaired immunity. 2. **Introduction of adaptive susceptibility**: - This paper introduces the concept of adaptive susceptibility, that is, after an individual is first exposed to an infection, its susceptibility to reinfection may change. This change can be a decrease (partial immunity) or an increase (impaired immunity). This feature makes the model closer to real - life situations and better able to describe contagion processes in biological, social, and technological systems. 3. **Four dynamic behavior patterns**: - The paper proves that the network SIRI model has four dynamic behavior patterns under different parameters and network structure conditions: no infection, epidemic, endemic, and bistability. Among them, bistability is a situation not covered by traditional models, which is manifested as a sudden outbreak of a new epidemic in an apparently non - infected state. 4. **Design of control strategies**: - Based on the predictive ability of the model, the paper shows how to design control strategies to mitigate harmful contagion behaviors. For example, in social networks, individual cognitive immunity can be enhanced by pre - exposing information, thereby combating the spread of false information. ### Main contributions of the model - **Theoretical analysis**: - Provides a strict stability analysis of the network SIRI model and proves the existence conditions of the Infection - Free Equilibria (IFE) and the Endemic Equilibrium (EE). - **Four dynamic behavior patterns**: - For the first time, strictly proves the existence of bistability and analyzes its geometric features and behaviors in detail. - **Application of control strategies**: - Shows how to use the model results to design control strategies to ensure the desired steady - state behavior through a heterogeneous agent network with adaptive susceptibility. ### Formula summary The formulas involved in the paper include but are not limited to: - **Basic reproduction number**: \[ R_0=\rho(BD^{-1}),\quad R_1 = \rho(\hat{B}D^{-1}) \] where \(B\) and \(\hat{B}\) are the infection matrix and the reinfection matrix respectively, and \(D\) is the recovery matrix. - **Maximum and minimum basic reproduction numbers**: \[ R_{\max}=\max_{0\preceq p\preceq1}\rho(B^*(p)D^{-1}),\quad R_{\min}=\min_{0\preceq p\preceq1}\rho(B^*(p)D^{-1}) \] - **Jacobian matrix**: \[ J_{EE}=\begin{bmatrix} -\text{diag}(Bp_I^*)&\bar{0}\\ \text{diag}((B - \hat{B})p_I^*)&J_a \end{bmatrix} \] where \(J_a=\hat{B}-D - P_I^*\hat{B}-\text{diag}(\hat{B}p_I^*)\). Through these formulas and analyses, the paper provides a comprehensive understanding of the network SIRI model, laying the foundation for further research and practical applications.