Abstract:Background Antitumor immunity is highly heterogeneous between individuals; however, underlying mechanisms remain elusive, despite their potential to improve personalized cancer immunotherapy. Head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (HNSCCs) vary significantly in immune infiltration and therapeutic responses between patients, demanding a mouse model with appropriate heterogeneity to investigate mechanistic differences. Methods We developed a unique HNSCC mouse model to investigate underlying mechanisms of heterogeneous antitumor immunity. This model system may provide a better control for tumor-intrinsic and host-genetic variables, thereby uncovering the contribution of the adaptive immunity to tumor eradication. We employed single-cell T-cell receptor (TCR) sequencing coupled with single-cell RNA sequencing to identify the difference in TCR repertoire of CD8 tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TILs) and the unique activation states linked with different TCR clonotypes. Results We discovered that genetically identical wild-type recipient mice responded heterogeneously to the same squamous cell carcinoma tumors orthotopically transplanted into the buccal mucosa. While tumors initially grew in 100% of recipients and most developed aggressive tumors, ~25% of recipients reproducibly eradicated tumors without intervention. Heterogeneous antitumor responses were dependent on CD8 T cells. Consistently, CD8 TILs in regressing tumors were significantly increased and more activated. Single-cell TCR-sequencing revealed that CD8 TILs from both growing and regressing tumors displayed evidence of clonal expansion compared with splenic controls. However, top TCR clonotypes and TCR specificity groups appear to be mutually exclusive between regressing and growing TILs. Furthermore, many TCRα/TCRβ sequences only occur in one recipient. By coupling single-cell transcriptomic analysis with unique TCR clonotypes, we found that top TCR clonotypes clustered in distinct activation states in regressing versus growing TILs. Intriguingly, the few TCR clonotypes shared between regressors and progressors differed greatly in their activation states, suggesting a more dominant influence from tumor microenvironment than TCR itself on T cell activation status. Conclusions We reveal that intrinsic differences in the TCR repertoire of TILs and their different transcriptional trajectories may underlie the heterogeneous antitumor immune responses in different hosts. We suggest that antitumor immune responses are highly individualized and different hosts employ different TCR specificities against the same tumors, which may have important implications for developing personalized cancer immunotherapy.

How heterogeneous thymic output and homeostatic proliferation shape naive T cell receptor clone abundance distributions

Preselection TCR repertoire predicts CD4<SUP>+</SUP>and CD8<SUP>+</SUP>T-cell differentiation state

Heterogeneity and plasticity of the naive CD4+ T cell compartment

Fluctuating fitness shapes the clone size distribution of immune repertoires

Variability in the local and global composition of human T-cell receptor repertoires during thymic development across cell types and individuals

Persisting fetal clonotypes influence the structure and overlap of adult human T cell receptor repertoires

Mathematical Characterization of Private and Public Immune Repertoire Sequences

High Throughput Sequencing Of T Cell Antigen Receptors Reveals A Conserved Tcr Repertoire

How many different clonotypes do immune repertoires contain?

The splenic T cell receptor repertoire during an immune response against a complex antigen: Expanding private clones accumulate in the high and low copy number region.

The TCR assigns naive T cells to a preferred lymph node

Sex- and age-specific aspects of human peripheral T-cell dynamics

Shorter TCR Β-Chains Are Highly Enriched During Thymic Selection and Antigen-Driven Selection

Recombinatorial Biases and Convergent Recombination Determine Interindividual TCRβ Sharing in Murine Thymocytes

Population variability in the generation and thymic selection of T-cell repertoires

Analysis of the Recent Thymic Output Function of 23 TCR Vβ Subfamily Naïve T Cells in Patients with AML.

Preselection TCR repertoire predicts CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell differentiation state

How nonuniform contact profiles of T cell receptors modulate thymic selection outcomes

Analysis of the Repertoire Features of TCR Beta Chain CDR3 in Human by High-Throughput Sequencing

The shape of the lymphocyte receptor repertoire: lessons from the B cell receptor.

Differences in TCR repertoire and T cell activation underlie the divergent outcomes of antitumor immune responses in tumor-eradicating versus tumor-progressing hosts