Implications of gamma-ray and neutrino observations on source models of ultrahigh energy cosmic rays

A.D. Supanitsky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1905.08679

2019-05-21

Abstract:The origin and nature of the ultrahigh energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) are still unknown. However, great progress has been achieved in past years due to the observations performed by the Pierre Auger Observatory and Telescope Array. Above $10^{18}$ eV the observed energy spectrum presents two features: a hardening of the slope at about $10^{18.7}$ eV, which is known as the ankle and a suppression at approximately $10^{19.6}$ eV. The composition inferred from the experimental data, interpreted by using the current high energy hadronic interaction models, seems to be light below the ankle, showing a trend to heavier nuclei for increasing values of the primary energy. Current high energy hadronic interaction models, updated by using Large Hadron Collider data, are still subject to large systematic uncertainties, which makes difficult the interpretation of the experimental data in terms of composition. On the other hand, it is very well known that gamma rays and neutrinos are produced by UHECRs during propagation from their sources, as a consequence of their interactions with the radiation field present in the universe. The flux at Earth of these secondary particles depends on the source models of UHECRs including the chemical composition at injection. Therefore, both gamma-ray and neutrino observations can be used to constrain source models of UHECRs, including the composition in a way which is independent of the high energy hadronic interaction models. In this article I will review recent results obtained by using the latest gamma-ray and neutrino observations.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the impact of gamma - ray and neutrino observations on the source models of ultra - high - energy cosmic rays (UHECRs). Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:

1. **Origin and Properties of Ultra - High - Energy Cosmic Rays**: Despite significant progress made in recent years through observations at the Pierre Auger Observatory and the Telescope Array, the origin and properties of ultra - high - energy cosmic rays remain an unsolved mystery. These observations have revealed the hardening of the energy spectrum at approximately \(10^{18.7}\) eV (known as the "ankle") and the suppression at approximately \(10^{19.6}\) eV.

2. **Uncertainties in Composition Analysis**: Current high - energy hadronic interaction models (HEHIMs) have large systematic errors, which make it difficult to infer the cosmic - ray composition based on experimental data. The model uncertainties are particularly evident when extrapolating low - energy accelerator data to the highest - energy regions.

3. **Production Mechanisms of Gamma - rays and Neutrinos**: Ultra - high - energy cosmic rays interact with the radiation fields in the universe during their propagation, producing gamma - rays and neutrinos. The fluxes of these secondary particles can be used to constrain the source models of cosmic rays, including their chemical compositions. Observations of gamma - rays and neutrinos provide a method independent of high - energy hadronic interaction models to study the composition of cosmic rays.

4. **Constraints on Models**: Using the latest gamma - ray and neutrino observation data, the paper evaluates the feasibility of different source models. In particular, the paper explores the applicability of proton models and mixed - composition models and points out that proton models with strong evolution (i.e., source density varies significantly with redshift) are inconsistent with current gamma - ray and neutrino observations.

5. **Prospects for Future Observations**: The paper also discusses the neutrino fluxes that may be detected by the next - generation neutrino observatories, especially under the mixed - composition model, and these fluxes may be detected in future observations.

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to use gamma - ray and neutrino observation data to strictly constrain the source models of ultra - high - energy cosmic rays and explore the feasibility of different models and the directions for future research.