Pricing under Fairness Concerns

Erik Eyster,Kristof Madarasz,Pascal Michaillat

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvaa041

2020-08-01

Abstract:This paper proposes a theory of pricing premised upon the assumptions that customers dislike unfair prices---those marked up steeply over cost---and that firms take these concerns into account when setting prices. Since they do not observe firms' costs, customers must extract costs from prices. The theory assumes that customers infer less than rationally: when a price rises due to a cost increase, customers partially misattribute the higher price to a higher markup---which they find unfair. Firms anticipate this response and trim their price increases, which drives the passthrough of costs into prices below one: prices are somewhat rigid. Embedded in a New Keynesian model as a replacement for the usual pricing frictions, our theory produces monetary nonneutrality: when monetary policy loosens and inflation rises, customers misperceive markups as higher and feel unfairly treated; firms mitigate this perceived unfairness by reducing their markups; in general equilibrium, employment rises. The theory also features a hybrid short-run Phillips curve, realistic impulse responses of output and employment to monetary and technology shocks, and an upward-sloping long-run Phillips curve.

Theoretical Economics,General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the problem of price rigidity, that is, prices are neither completely fixed nor completely change with costs. The authors propose a pricing theory based on fairness considerations, attempting to explain why enterprises will take into account consumers' sense of fairness when setting prices and how this consideration leads to price rigidity.

Specifically, the paper assumes that consumers do not like prices that are significantly higher than marginal costs and consider these prices unfair. Since consumers cannot directly observe the costs of enterprises, they must infer costs from prices. However, such inferences by consumers are often not completely rational. When prices rise due to cost increases, consumers partially and wrongly attribute the higher prices to higher mark - ups, which makes them feel unfair. Enterprises foresee such reactions from consumers, so they will not fully increase prices when costs increase, resulting in a cost - to - price pass - through rate of less than 1, that is, prices show a certain degree of rigidity.

By embedding this theory into the New Keynesian model, the paper also explores the impact of this pricing mechanism based on fairness considerations on the macro - economy, including the effectiveness of monetary policy, the form of the Phillips curve, and the output and employment responses after economic shocks. The paper points out that this pricing mechanism can explain why consumers will be dissatisfied because they perceive higher mark - ups during inflationary periods. In order to reduce this dissatisfaction, enterprises will reduce mark - ups, thereby stimulating economic activities. In addition, the paper also predicts the slope of the long - term Phillips curve, indicating that in the long run, a higher inflation level will lead to a higher employment level.