Skyrmion-like textures in superconductors with competing order

V. Saran,Madhuparna Karmakar,R. Ganesh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.100.104520

2019-03-27

Abstract:Vortex cores in a superconductor can develop structure and manifest competing orders. In strong magnetic fields, the inter-vortex distance can become short enough for vortex cores to overlap, giving rise to long ranged textures. We show that spin orbit coupling (SOC) can modify the interaction between vortex cores to give rise to undulating competing order fields. We illustrate this using the SO(3) theory of competing orders, wherein superconductivity and a scalar order form a three-component vector field. We consider a spherical surface with a radial magnetic flux that creates two vortices. We find stationary solutions where both vortex cores develop competing order in (a) the same sense, and (b) opposite senses. The latter represents a topologically stable vector configuration analogous to a single skyrmion. Its free energy is lowered when SOC is introduced, making it the ground state beyond a threshold SOC strength. We study this physics on the two dimensional plane using the attractive Hubbard model with Rashba SOC. Here, charge density wave (CDW) order competes with superconductivity. We find phases with long ranged, but spatially modulated, CDW order where the average CDW moment vanishes. In a wide range of parameters, CDW loses its rigidity as SOC lowers the energy cost for domain wall formation. We discuss consequences for systems such as the cuprates where charge order develops without a sharp diffraction peak.

Superconductivity,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how the vortex cores in superconductors develop structures and exhibit competing orders under strong magnetic fields. Specifically, when the distance between vortices becomes short enough under the influence of a strong magnetic field, the vortex cores will overlap, forming long - range textures. The paper explores how spin - orbit coupling (SOC) changes the interactions between vortex cores, thereby generating a fluctuating competing - order field. By using SO(3) theory to describe the competition between superconductivity and scalar order (such as charge - density - wave CDW), the authors show that under certain conditions, a topologically stable vector configuration similar to a single skyrmion can be formed. In addition, the paper also studies the competition relationship between charge - density - wave order and superconductivity in the two - dimensional plane after introducing Rashba spin - orbit coupling in the attractive Hubbard model, as well as the influence of this competition on material properties.

### Main problem summary:
1. **Structure and competing order of vortex cores**: Under strong magnetic fields, the overlap between vortex cores leads to the emergence of competing orders, especially the anti - correlated core order.
2. **Role of spin - orbit coupling**: How spin - orbit coupling affects the interactions between vortex cores, thereby stabilizing a skyrmion - like topological structure.
3. **Competition of charge - density - wave order**: In the two - dimensional plane, the competition relationship between charge - density - wave order and superconductivity, especially the phase - diagram changes after introducing Rashba spin - orbit coupling.

### Specific problem analysis:
- **Anti - correlated order of vortex cores**: Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, the paper shows that under certain conditions, vortex cores can develop competing orders in the same or opposite directions. The configuration of the opposite - direction order is similar to a single skyrmion and has topological stability.
- **Effect of spin - orbit coupling**: The introduction of spin - orbit coupling can reduce the free energy of the opposite - direction - order configuration, making it the ground state when it exceeds a certain threshold. This indicates that spin - orbit coupling plays a crucial role in stabilizing these topological structures.
- **Mode modulation of charge - density - wave order**: In the attractive Hubbard model, after introducing Rashba spin - orbit coupling, the charge - density - wave order can form a long - range order with spatial modulation, in which the average charge - density - wave moment disappears. This implies that the rigidity of the charge - density - wave order is reduced under the action of spin - orbit coupling.

### Mathematical formulas:
- **Lagrangian of SO(3) theory**:
\[
L=\frac{\chi}{2}\left|(\nabla - 2ie\frac{A}{\hbar})\Delta(\mathbf{r})\right|^{2}+\frac{1}{8\pi}(\nabla\times\mathbf{A})^{2}+\frac{\chi}{2}|\nabla\rho(\mathbf{r})|^{2}-|\Delta(\mathbf{r})|^{2}-(1 - \delta)|\rho(\mathbf{r})|^{2}
\]
where \(\Delta\) and \(\rho\) represent the superconducting - order parameter and the competing - order parameter (such as charge - density - wave), respectively, and \(\delta\) represents the energy difference between the two orders.

- **Spin - orbit coupling term**:
\[
L_{\text{SOC}}=i\lambda\hat{\mathbf{r}}\cdot\{D\Delta\times D\Delta^{*}\}
\]
where \(D = \nabla - 2ie\frac{A}{\hbar}\) is the gauge - invariant gradient operator.

### Conclusion:
Through theoretical analysis and numerical simulation, this paper reveals the important role of spin - orbit coupling in the formation of competing orders in vortex cores in superconductors, especially how to stabilize skyrmion - like topological structures. These findings are of great significance for understanding phase competition and vortex physics in superconducting materials.