Non-spherical equilibrium shapes in the liquid drop model

Rupert L. Frank

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5095603

2019-04-30

Abstract:We prove the existence of a family of volume-constrained critical points of the liquid drop functional, which are cylindrically but not spherically symmetric. This family bifurcates from the ball and exchanges stability with it.

Mathematical Physics,Analysis of PDEs

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Delaunay-like compact equilibria in the liquid drop model

Manuel del Pino,Monica Musso,Andrés Zúñiga

2024-09-23

Abstract:The liquid drop model was introduced by Gamow in 1928 and Bohr-Wheeler in 1938 to model atomic nuclei. The model describes the competition between the surface tension, which keeps the nuclei together, and the Coulomb force, corresponding to repulsion among protons. More precisely, the problem consists of finding a surface $\Sigma =\partial \Omega$ in $\mathbb{R}^3$ that is critical for the energy $$ E(\Omega) = {\rm Per\,} (\Omega ) + \frac 12 \int_\Omega\int_\Omega \frac {dxdy}{|x-y|} $$ under the volume constraint $|\Omega| = m$. The term ${\rm Per\,} (\Omega ) $ corresponds to the surface area of $\Sigma$. The associated Euler-Lagrange equation is $$ H_\Sigma (x) + \int_{\Omega } \frac {dy}{|x-y|} = \lambda \quad \hbox{ for all } x\in \Sigma, \quad $$ where $H_\Sigma$ stands for the mean curvature of the surface, and where $\lambda\in\mathbb{R}$ is the Lagrange multiplier associated to the constraint $|\Omega|=m$. Round spheres enclosing balls of volume $m$ are always solutions. They are minimizers for sufficiently small $m$. Since the two terms in the energy compete, finding non-minimizing solutions can be challenging. We find a new class of compact, embedded solutions with large volumes, whose geometry resembles a "pearl necklace" with an axis located on a large circle, with a shape close to a Delaunay's unduloid surface of constant mean curvature. The existence of such equilibria is not at all obvious, since for the closely related constant mean curvature problem $H_\Sigma = \lambda$, the only compact embedded solutions are spheres, as stated by the classical Alexandrov result.

Analysis of PDEs
On the Shape of Small Liquid Drops Minimizing Nonlocal Energies

Konstantinos Bessas,Matteo Novaga,Fumihiko Onoue

2023-04-14

Abstract:We study the equilibrium shape of liquid drops minimizing the fractional perimeter under the action of a potential energy. We prove, with a quantitative estimate, that the small volume minimizers are convex and uniformly close to a ball.

Analysis of PDEs
Stability of rotating liquid drops with surface tension

Keiichi Watanabe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00028-024-00986-3

2024-06-26

Journal of Evolution Equations

Abstract:The aim of this paper is to investigate the stability of a stationary solution of free boundary problems of the incompressible Navier–Stokes equations in a three-dimensional bounded domain with surface tension. More precisely, this article proves that if the initial angular momentum is sufficiently small and if the initial configuration is sufficiently close to equilibrium, then there exists a global classical solution that converges exponentially fast to a uniform rigid rotation of the liquid as with respect to a certain axis. The proof of the unique existence of a stationary solution is also given.

mathematics, applied
Stability and Bifurcation of A Rotating Planar Liquid-Drop

D LEWIS,J MARSDEN,T RATIU

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.527740

IF: 1.469

1987-01-01

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Abstract:The stability and symmetry breaking bifurcation of a planar liquid drop is studied using the energy-Casimir method and singularity theory. It is shown that a rigidly rotating circular drop of radius r with surface tension coefficient τ and angular velocity Ω/2 is stable if (Ω/2)2 <3τ/r3. A new branch of stable rigidly rotating relative equilibria invariant under rotation through π and reflection across two axes bifurcates from the branch of circular solutions when (Ω/2)2=3τ/r3.
Exponential stability of a free boundary problem with spherical symmetry for a gas bubble immersed in a bounded incompressible liquid

Chengchun Hao,Tao Luo,Siqi Yang

2024-08-29

Abstract:This paper is mainly concerned with the free boundary problem for an approximate model (for example, arising from the study of sonoluminescence) of a gas bubble of finite mass enclosed within a bounded incompressible viscous liquid, accounting for surface tensions at both the gas-liquid interface and the external free surface of the entire gas-liquid region. It is found that any regular spherically symmetric steady-state solution is characterized by a positive root of a ninth-degree polynomial for which the existence and uniqueness are proved and a one-to-one correspondence between equilibria and pairs of gas mass and liquid volume is established. We prove that these equilibria exhibit nonlinear and exponential asymptotic stability under small perturbations that conserve gas mass and liquid volume, and an equilibrium solution acts as a local minimizer of the energy functional, even under relatively large perturbations, with the proportionality constant determined by the adiabatic constant. Moreover, we construct a global center manifold to apply the center manifold theory. Our results apply to gases and liquids of all sizes. Furthermore, we derive the optimal exponential decay rate for small liquid volumes by analyzing the spectrum bounds of the associated linear operator and show that decreasing the gas mass or increasing the temperature can accelerate the convergence rate, a behavior not seen in unbounded liquid scenarios.

Analysis of PDEs
Multiple-Lobed Bifurcation of Rotating Liquid Drops Levitated by Ultrasound

Y. J. Lue,W. J. Xie,B. Wei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3276250

IF: 2.877

2010-01-01

Journal of Applied Physics

Abstract:It is previously predicted that the equilibrium shape of a rotating liquid drop evolves from the axisymmetric to the two-, three-, and four-lobed morphologies as the angular velocity increases. Although the two- and three-lobed shape bifurcations have been observed in experiments, the four-lobed equilibrium shape is scarcely reported. Here, we investigate the multiple-lobed shape bifurcations of rotating drops by using acoustic levitation, and in particular, follow the evolution of the four-lobed equilibrium shape. A new shape family of rotating drops characterized by five-lobed bifurcation is also observed, which is unexpected in the theoretical predictions. A numerical method is employed to simulate the shape evolution of acoustically levitated and rotating drops. And the results validate the existence of bifurcation point shifts among all the lobed-shape families due to the initial drop flattening induced by the acoustic radiation pressure, which plays a decisive role in the emergence of the five-lobed shape.
Liquid drop with capillarity and rotating traveling waves

Pietro Baldi,Vesa Julin,Domenico Angelo La Manna

2024-08-05

Abstract:We consider the free boundary problem for a 3-dimensional, incompressible, irrotational liquid drop of nearly spherical shape with capillarity. We study the problem from scratch, extending some classical results from the flat case (capillary water waves) to the spherical geometry: the reduction to a problem on the boundary, its Hamiltonian structure, the analyticity and tame estimates for the Dirichlet-Neumann operator in Sobolev class, and a linearization formula for it, both with the method of the good unknown of Alinhac and by a differential geometry approach. Then we prove the bifurcation of traveling waves, which are nontrivial (i.e., nonspherical) fixed profiles rotating with constant angular velocity.

Analysis of PDEs
On minimizers in the liquid drop model

Otis Chodosh,Ian Ruohoniemi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/cpa.22229

2024-10-07

Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics

Abstract:We prove that round balls of volume ≤1 uniquely minimize in Gamow's liquid drop model.

mathematics, applied
Free boundary problem for a gas bubble in a liquid, and exponential stability of the manifold of spherically symmetric equilibria

Chen-Chih Lai,Michael I. Weinstein

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00205-023-01927-z

2023-10-04

Abstract:We consider the dynamics of a gas bubble immersed in an incompressible fluid of fixed temperature, and focus on the relaxation of an expanding and contracting spherically symmetric bubble due to thermal effects. We study two models, both systems of PDEs with an evolving free boundary: the full mathematical model as well as an approximate model, arising for example in the study of sonoluminescence. For fixed physical parameters (surface tension of the gas-liquid interface, liquid viscosity, thermal conductivity of the gas, etc.), both models share a family of spherically symmetric equilibria, smoothly parametrized by the mass of the gas bubble. Our main result concerns the approximate model. We prove the nonlinear asymptotic stability of the manifold of equilibria with respect to small spherically symmetric perturbations. The rate of convergence is exponential in time. To prove this result we first prove a weak form of nonlinear asymptotic stability -- with no explicit rate of time-decay -- using the energy dissipation law, and then, via a center manifold analysis, bootstrap the weak time-decay to exponential time-decay. We also study the uniqueness of the family of spherically symmetric equilibria within each model. The family of spherically symmetric equilibria captures all regular spherically symmetric equilibria of the approximate system. However within the full model, this family is embedded in a larger family of spherically symmetric solutions. For the approximate system, we prove that all equilibrium bubbles are spherically symmetric, by an application of Alexandrov's theorem on closed surfaces of constant mean curvature.

Analysis of PDEs,Mathematical Physics,Pattern Formation and Solitons
Torus-like solutions for the Landau-de Gennes model. Part II: Topology of S 1 -equivariant minimizers

Federico Luigi Dipasquale,Vincent Millot,Adriano Pisante

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfa.2024.110314

IF: 1.891

2024-04-01

Journal of Functional Analysis

Abstract:We study energy minimization of a continuum Landau-de Gennes energy functional for nematic liquid crystals, in a three-dimensional axisymmetric domain and in a restricted class of S 1 -equivariant (i.e., axially symmetric) configurations. We assume smooth and nonvanishing S 1 -equivariant (e.g. homeotropic) Dirichlet boundary condition and a physically relevant norm constraint (the Lyuksyutov constraint) in the interior. Relying on our previous results in the nonsymmetric setting [16], we prove partial regularity of minimizers away from a possible finite set of interior singularities located on the symmetry axis. For a suitable class of domains and boundary data, we show that for smooth minimizers (torus solutions) the level sets of the signed biaxiality are generically finite unions of tori of revolution. Concerning nonsmooth minimizers (split solutions), we characterize their asymptotic behavior around any singular point in terms of explicit S 1 -equivariant harmonic maps into S 4 , whence the generic level sets of the signed biaxiality contains invariant topological spheres. Finally, in the model case of a nematic droplet, we provide existence of torus solutions, at least when the boundary data are suitable uniaxial deformations of the radial anchoring, and existence of split solutions for boundary data which are suitable linearly full harmonic spheres.

mathematics
Bifurcation and fission in the liquid drop model: a phase-field approach

Zirui Xu,Qiang Du

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0148456

2023-07-26

Abstract:The liquid drop model, originally used to model atomic nuclei, describes the competition between surface tension and Coulomb force. To help understand how a ball loses stability and becomes prone to fission, we calculate the minimum energy path of the fission process, and study the bifurcation branch conjectured by Bohr and Wheeler. We then present the two-dimensional analogue for comparison. Our study is conducted with the help of numerical simulations via a phase-field approach.

Classical Physics,Mathematical Physics,Computational Physics
Liquid Drops on a Rough Surface

William M. Feldman,Inwon C. Kim

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1612.07261

2016-12-22

Abstract:We consider a liquid drop sitting on a rough solid surface at equilibrium, a volume constrained minimizer of the total interfacial energy. The large-scale shape of such a drop strongly depends on the micro-structure of the solid surface. Surface roughness enhances hydrophilicity and hydrophobicity properties of the surface, altering the equilibrium contact angle between the drop and the surface. Our goal is to understand the shape of the drop with fixed small scale roughness. To achieve this, we develop a quantitative description of the drop and its contact line in the context of periodic homogenization theory, building on the qualitative theory of Alberti and DeSimone.

Analysis of PDEs
Symmetry Breaking in Drop Bouncing on Curved Surfaces.

Yahua Liu,Matthew Andrew,Jing Li,Julia M. Yeomans,Zuankai Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms10034

IF: 16.6

2015-01-01

Nature Communications

Abstract:The impact of liquid drops on solid surfaces is ubiquitous in nature, and of practical importance in many industrial processes. A drop hitting a flat surface retains a circular symmetry throughout the impact process. Here we show that a drop impinging on Echevaria leaves exhibits asymmetric bouncing dynamics with distinct spreading and retraction along two perpendicular directions. This is a direct consequence of the cylindrical leaves that have a convex/concave architecture of size comparable to the drop. Systematic experimental investigations on mimetic surfaces and lattice Boltzmann simulations reveal that this novel phenomenon results from an asymmetric momentum and mass distribution that allows for preferential fluid pumping around the drop rim. The asymmetry of the bouncing leads to ∼40% reduction in contact time.
A spherical rearrangement proof of the stability of a Riesz-type inequality and an application to an isoperimetric type problem

Giacomo Ascione

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2105.08012

2021-10-20

Abstract:We prove the stability of the ball as global minimizer of an attractive shape functional under volume constraint, by means of mass transportation arguments. The stability exponent is $1/2$ and it is sharp. Moreover, we use such stability result together with the quantitative (possibly fractional) isoperimetric inequality to prove that the ball is a global minimizer of a shape functional involving both an attractive and a repulsive term with a sufficiently large fixed volume and with a suitable (possibly fractional) perimeter penalization.

Functional Analysis,Analysis of PDEs
On Floating Equilibria in a Laterally Finite Container

John McCuan,Ray Treinen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1137/16m1088818

IF: 1.9

2018-01-01

SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics

Abstract:The main contribution of this paper is the precise numerical identification of a model set of parameters for a floating object/container system which admits three distinct equilibrium configurations, two of which are local energy minimizers among pseudo-equilibrium configurations. This numerical result strongly suggests the existence of a physical system in which a circular object can be observed to float in a centrally symmetric position in two geometrically distinct configurations, i.e., at two different heights. Thus, the general dependence of observable stable equilibria on the physical parameters of the problem is both shown to be much more complicated than originally anticipated and likely to depend on additional information, e.g., the initial positioning of the floating object. We show the existence of at least one equilibrium configuration in any situation which the density of the floating object is less than that of the liquid bath. We also give a collection of conditions under which all equilibrium fluid interfaces can be shown to project simply onto the base of the container.

mathematics, applied
Torus-like solutions for the Landau-de Gennes model. Part III: torus vs split minimizers

Federico Luigi Dipasquale,Vincent Millot,Adriano Pisante

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00526-024-02743-3

2024-05-29

Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations

Abstract:We study the behaviour of global minimizers of a continuum Landau–de Gennes energy functional for nematic liquid crystals, in three-dimensional axially symmetric domains diffeomorphic to a ball (a nematic droplet) and in a restricted class of -equivariant configurations. It is known from our previous paper (Dipasquale et al. in J Funct Anal 286:110314, 2024) that, assuming smooth and uniaxial (e.g. homeotropic) boundary conditions and a physically relevant norm constraint in the interior (Lyuksyutov constraint), minimizing configurations are either of torus or of split type. Here, starting from a nematic droplet with the homeotropic boundary condition, we show how singular (split) solutions or smooth (torus) solutions (or even both) for the Euler–Lagrange equations do appear as energy minimizers by suitably deforming either the domain or the boundary data. As a consequence, we derive symmetry breaking results for the minimization among all competitors.

mathematics, applied
Liquid Crystals on Deformable Surfaces

Ingo Nitschke,Sebastian Reuther,Axel Voigt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.2020.0313

2019-11-25

Abstract:Liquid crystals with molecules constrained to the tangent bundle of a curved surface show interesting phenomena resulting from the tight coupling of the elastic and bulk free energies of the liquid crystal with geometric properties of the surface. We derive thermodynamically consistent Frank-Oseen-Helfrich and Landau-de Gennes-Helfrich models which consider the simultaneous relaxation of the director/Q-tensor fields and the surface. The resulting systems of vector- or tensor-valued surface partial differential equation and geometric evolution laws are numerically solved to tackle the rich dynamics of these systems and to compute the resulting equilibrium shapes. The results strongly depend on the intrinsic and extrinsic curvature contributions and can lead to unexpected asymmetric shapes.

Soft Condensed Matter
Relaxation of nonspherical sessile drops towards equilibrium

Vadim Nikolayev,Daniel Beysens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.65.046135

2016-01-26

Abstract:We present a theoretical study related to a recent experiment on the coalescence of sessile drops. The study deals with the kinetics of relaxation towards equilibrium, under the action of surface tension, of a spheroidal drop on a flat surface. For such a nonspherical drop under partial wetting conditions, the dynamic contact angle varies along the contact line. We propose a new nonlocal approach to the wetting dynamics, where the contact line velocity depends on the geometry of the whole drop. We compare our results to those of the conventional approach in which the contact line velocity depends only on the local value of the dynamic contact angle. The influence on drop dynamics of the pinning of the contact line by surface defects is also discussed.

Soft Condensed Matter,Fluid Dynamics
Liquid toroidal drop in compressional flow with arbitrary drop-to-ambient fluid viscosity ratio

Michael Zabarankin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.2015.0737

2016-03-01

Abstract:Existing experiments show that a sufficiently fat toroidal drop freely suspended in another liquid shrinks towards its centre to form a spherical drop. However, recent simulations reveal that if a liquid torus with circular cross section is embedded in a compressional same-viscosity flow that acts to expand the torus, then depending on the torus radius R and a capillary number Ca characterizing the balance between the viscous forces and the interfacial tension, the torus may either coalesce, expand indefinitely or attain a stationary shape. For each Ca less than 0.2, there is a single value of R , called the critical radius, for which the torus attains the stationary shape. Here, the drop-to-ambient fluid viscosity ratio, λ, is assumed to be arbitrary. The corresponding two-phase Stokes flow problem is solved for a liquid toroidal drop with circular cross section in terms of stream functions in the toroidal coordinates. When λ=1, the stream functions admit a closed-form integral representation for a drop of arbitrary axisymmetric shape. ‘Stationary’ circular tori minimize a certain measure of the normal velocity over the interface, and as in the case of λ=1, their radii are expected to predict the critical ones for arbitrary λ and Ca in a certain range (e.g. for Ca<0.2 when λ=1). Streamlines about ‘stationary’ circular tori are analysed for various Ca and λ.

Non-spherical equilibrium shapes in the liquid drop model

Delaunay-like compact equilibria in the liquid drop model

On the Shape of Small Liquid Drops Minimizing Nonlocal Energies

Stability of rotating liquid drops with surface tension

Stability and Bifurcation of A Rotating Planar Liquid-Drop

Exponential stability of a free boundary problem with spherical symmetry for a gas bubble immersed in a bounded incompressible liquid

Multiple-Lobed Bifurcation of Rotating Liquid Drops Levitated by Ultrasound

Liquid drop with capillarity and rotating traveling waves

On minimizers in the liquid drop model

Free boundary problem for a gas bubble in a liquid, and exponential stability of the manifold of spherically symmetric equilibria

Torus-like solutions for the Landau-de Gennes model. Part II: Topology of S 1 -equivariant minimizers

Bifurcation and fission in the liquid drop model: a phase-field approach

Liquid Drops on a Rough Surface

Symmetry Breaking in Drop Bouncing on Curved Surfaces.

A spherical rearrangement proof of the stability of a Riesz-type inequality and an application to an isoperimetric type problem

On Floating Equilibria in a Laterally Finite Container

Torus-like solutions for the Landau-de Gennes model. Part III: torus vs split minimizers

Liquid Crystals on Deformable Surfaces

Relaxation of nonspherical sessile drops towards equilibrium

Liquid toroidal drop in compressional flow with arbitrary drop-to-ambient fluid viscosity ratio