Breakdown of the Hebel-Slichter effect in superconducting graphene due to the emergence of Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states at magnetic resonant scatterers

Denis Kochan,Michael Barth,Andreas Costa,Klaus Richter,Jaroslav Fabian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.087001

2020-05-22

Abstract:Employing analytical methods and quantum transport simulations we investigate the relaxation of quasiparticle spins in graphene proximitized by an $s$-wave superconductor in the presence of resonant magnetic and spin-orbit active impurities. Off resonance, the relaxation increases with decreasing temperature when electrons scatter off magnetic impurities---the Hebel-Slichter effect---and decreases when impurities have spin-orbit coupling. This distinct temperature~dependence (not present in the normal state) uniquely discriminates between the two scattering mechanisms. However, we show that the Hebel-Slichter picture breaks down at resonances. The emergence of Yu-Shiba-Rusinov bound states within the superconducting gap redistributes the spectral weight away from magnetic resonances. The result is opposite to the Hebel-Slichter expectation: the spin relaxation decreases with decreasing temperature. Our findings hold for generic $s$-wave superconductors with resonant magnetic impurities, but also, as we show, for resonant magnetic Josephson junctions.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the problem of the failure of the Hebel - Slichter effect due to the emergence of Yu - Shiba - Rusinov (YSR) states caused by resonant magnetic scatterers in superconducting graphene (SCG). Specifically, through analytical methods and quantum transport simulations, the researchers studied the behavior of quasiparticle spin relaxation in graphene adjacent to s - wave superconductors, especially in the presence of resonant magnetic and spin - orbit active impurities.

#### Main problems:

1. **Temperature dependence of the Hebel - Slichter effect**:
- When far from resonance, when electrons scatter from magnetic impurities, spin relaxation increases as the temperature decreases; while when the impurities have spin - orbit coupling, spin relaxation decreases.
- This temperature dependence does not exist in the normal state and can distinguish between the two scattering mechanisms.

2. **Failure of the Hebel - Slichter effect under resonant conditions**:
- It was found that under resonant conditions, YSR states form within the superconducting gap, redistributing the spectral weight, so that spin relaxation decreases as the temperature decreases, which is contrary to the expectation of the Hebel - Slichter effect.

3. **Possibility of experimental verification**:
- The research predicts that this effect is applicable not only to graphene, but also to all s - wave superconductors with resonant magnetic impurities, as well as Josephson junctions with magnetic tunnel barriers.
- Although spin relaxation has not yet been measured in SCG at present, these theoretical predictions provide a clear direction and verification means for future experiments.

#### Key conclusions:

- Under resonant conditions, due to the emergence of YSR states, the spin relaxation rate drops significantly, and this phenomenon can be strong evidence for identifying resonant magnetic impurities in experiments.
- This anomalous spin relaxation behavior may span three to four orders of magnitude, making it a robust and verifiable experimental tool.

Through these studies, the authors revealed the unique behavior of spin relaxation in superconducting graphene and provided a theoretical basis for future research and experiments.