Thermo-compositional diabatic convection in the atmospheres of brown dwarfs and in Earth's atmosphere and oceans

P. Tremblin,T. Padioleau,M. Phillips,G. Chabrier,I. Baraffe,S. Fromang,E. Audit,H. Bloch,A. J. Burgasser,B. Drummond,M. Gonzalez,P. Kestener,S. Kokh,P.-O. Lagage,M. Stauffert

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab05db

2019-02-10

Abstract:By generalizing the theory of convection to any type of thermal and compositional source terms (diabatic processes), we show that thermohaline convection in Earth oceans, fingering convection in stellar atmospheres, and moist convection in Earth atmosphere are deriving from the same general diabatic convective instability. We show also that "radiative convection" triggered by CO/CH4 transition with radiative transfer in the atmospheres of brown dwarfs is analog to moist and thermohaline convection. We derive a generalization of the mixing length theory to include the effect of source terms in 1D codes. We show that CO/CH4 radiative convection could significantly reduce the temperature gradient in the atmospheres of brown dwarfs similarly to moist convection in Earth atmosphere thus possibly explaining the reddening in brown-dwarf spectra. By using idealized two-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations in the Ledoux unstable regime, we show that compositional source terms can indeed provoke a reduction of the temperature gradient. The L/T transition could be explained by a bifurcation between the adiabatic and diabatic convective transports and could be seen as a giant cooling crisis: an analog of the boiling crisis in liquid/steam-water convective flows. This mechanism with other chemical transitions could be present in many giant and earth-like exoplanets. The study of the impact of different parameters (effective temperature, compositional changes) on CO/CH4 radiative convection and the analogy with Earth moist and thermohaline convection is opening the possibility to use brown dwarfs to better understand some aspects of the physics at play in the climate of our own planet.

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to promote the convection theory to include any type of heat source and composition source terms (non - adiabatic processes), thereby revealing that the thermohaline convection in the Earth's oceans, the fingering convection in stellar atmospheres, and the moist convection in the Earth's atmosphere all originate from the same type of generalized non - adiabatic convection instability. In addition, the paper also explores the "radiative convection" triggered by the CO/CH4 conversion in the atmospheres of brown dwarfs, which is similar to the moist convection and thermohaline convection on Earth. The goal of the paper is to use theoretical derivation and numerical simulation to show how these different types of convection affect the temperature gradients of their respective systems, and to propose that these mechanisms may explain the reddening of the spectra of brown dwarfs and the possible cooling crisis during the L/T transition process.

Specifically, the main contributions of the paper include:

1. **Theoretical generalization**: A generalized form of the convection theory is proposed, which can take into account any type of heat source and composition source terms, making the theory applicable to a wider range of physical systems.
2. **Mechanism unification**: It is shown that the thermohaline convection in the Earth's oceans, the fingering convection in stellar atmospheres, the moist convection in the Earth's atmosphere, and the CO/CH4 "radiative convection" in the atmospheres of brown dwarfs all originate from the same convection instability.
3. **Numerical simulation**: Using idealized two - dimensional hydrodynamic simulations, it is verified that under Ledoux unstable conditions, the composition source terms can indeed reduce the temperature gradient.
4. **Application prospects**: The potential applications of these mechanisms in understanding the climates of planets and terrestrial exoplanets are discussed, especially in understanding certain aspects of the Earth's climate by studying brown dwarfs.

Through these works, the paper provides a new perspective for understanding the common mechanisms of different types of convection processes and provides a theoretical basis for future astronomical and earth science research.