Abstract:Recent experiments claimed that the enhancement of catalytic reaction rates occurs via the reduction of activation barriers driven by non-equilibrium (``hot'') electrons in plasmonic metal nanoparticles. These experiments place plasmonic photo-catalysis as a promising path for enhancing the efficiency of various chemical reactions. Here, we argue that what appears to be photo-catalysis is in fact thermo-catalysis, driven by the well-known plasmon-enhanced ability of illuminated metallic nanoparticles to serve as heat sources. Specifically, we point to some of the most important papers in the field, and show that a simple theory of illumination-induced heating can explain the extracted experimental data to remarkable agreement, with minimal to no fit parameters. We further show that any small temperature difference between the photocatalysis experiment and a control experiment performed under uniform external heating is effectively amplified by the exponential sensitivity of the reaction, and very likely to be interpreted incorrectly as ``hot'' electron effects.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the relative importance of thermal and non - thermal effects (i.e., the "hot - electron" effect) in photocatalytic reactions. Specifically, some recent experiments claim that the reduction of activation energy barriers driven by non - equilibrium ("hot") electrons can enhance the catalytic reaction rate, and these "hot" electrons are generated after the decay of surface plasmons in metal nanoparticles. However, the authors of this paper believe that so - called photocatalysis is actually thermocatalysis, which is driven by the fact that metal nanoparticles under illumination become heat sources due to the known plasmon - enhancing ability. The main arguments of the paper are as follows: 1. **Thermal effects explain experimental data**: The authors propose a simple theory, indicating that heating caused by illumination can well explain the extracted experimental data with almost no fitting parameters. They further point out that any small temperature difference between photocatalytic experiments and control experiments carried out under uniform external heating conditions will be magnified due to the exponential sensitivity of the reaction to temperature, and thus may be misinterpreted as the "hot - electron" effect. 2. **Challenging existing views**: Most previous studies (both experimental and theoretical) have concluded that thermal effects are negligible compared to non - thermal electron effects. This conclusion has led to a rapid growth in interest in plasmon - assisted photocatalysis because it was thought that this method could bypass the limitations associated with thermocatalysis, such as high energy consumption, shortened catalyst life, and poor selectivity. 3. **Re - evaluating the importance of thermal effects**: This paper provides evidence that the effects observed in some well - known experiments are likely only due to the simple heating of nanoparticles, and non - thermal effects play almost no role in plasmon - assisted photocatalysis. The authors calculated the electron distribution and temperature based on first - principles theory and calculated the electron and phonon temperatures self - consistently for the first time. The results show that the generation efficiency of "hot" electrons is extremely low, and most of the absorbed energy is actually used for heating. 4. **Comparison between theory and experimental data**: The authors analyzed the experimental data in several key papers and pointed out the errors in the experimental design, which led the original authors to underestimate the temperature rise and, in turn, the role of thermal effects. By using a theory that only considers heating effects, the authors showed how to fit the main experimental results very well with minimal fitting parameters. In conclusion, this paper aims to re - evaluate the relative importance of thermal and non - thermal effects in plasmon - assisted photocatalysis and proposes a simpler thermal - effect model to explain the experimentally observed phenomena.

Thermal effects - an alternative mechanism for plasmonic-assisted photo-catalysis