Independence of Maxwell's equations: A Bäcklund-transformation view

C. J. Papachristou,A. N. Magoulas

2023-06-25

Abstract:It is now widely accepted that the Maxwell equations of Electrodynamics constitute a self-consistent set of four independent partial differential equations. According to a certain school of thought, however, half of these equations - namely, those expressing the two Gauss' laws for the electric and the magnetic field - are redundant since they can be "derived" from the remaining two laws and the principle of conservation of charge. The status of the latter principle is thus elevated to a law of Nature more fundamental than, say, Coulomb's law. In this note we examine this line of reasoning and we propose an approach according to which the Maxwell equations may be viewed as a Backlund transformation relating fields and sources. The conservation of charge and the electromagnetic wave equations then simply express the integrability conditions of this transformation.

Classical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

The paper primarily explores whether Gauss's laws in Maxwell's equations are redundant and proposes a novel perspective of viewing Maxwell's equations as a type of Bäcklund transformation.

#### Summary of Main Content
1. **Independence of Maxwell's Equations**:
- Maxwell's equations consist of four partial differential equations, typically considered self-consistent and mutually independent.
- Some scholars believe that Gauss's laws (the two equations describing the divergence of electric and magnetic fields) can be derived from the other two equations and the principle of charge conservation, thus deeming them redundant.
- The author of this paper points out logical flaws in this view, particularly the unrealistic assumption that electromagnetic fields are always absent in certain regions.

2. **Bäcklund Transformation Perspective**:
- The author proposes a new method of viewing Maxwell's equations as a Bäcklund transformation.
- By analyzing Maxwell's equations in free space, it is found that they can be seen as a type of Bäcklund transformation, where the wave equations for electric and magnetic fields are the integrability conditions of this transformation.
- For the complete Maxwell's equations that include source terms, the self-consistency of the Bäcklund transformation also requires certain constraints on the source terms.

3. **Conclusions**:
- Maxwell's equations consist of four independent natural laws, with each equation not derivable from the others.
- Charge conservation and the electromagnetic wave equation are necessary conditions for the self-consistency of Maxwell's equations but are not sufficient conditions.
- From a mathematical perspective, Maxwell's equations can be viewed as a type of Bäcklund transformation, with integrability conditions that include the wave equations for electric and magnetic fields as well as the charge conservation equation.

Through these analyses, the author emphasizes the independence and self-consistency of Maxwell's equations and provides a new perspective to understand the relationships between these equations.