Abstract:Navigating the physical world requires learning probabilistic associations between sensory events and their change in time (volatility). Bayesian accounts of this learning process rest on hierarchical prediction errors (PEs) that are weighted by estimates of uncertainty (or its inverse, precision). In a previous fMRI study we found that low-level precision-weighted PEs about visual outcomes (that update beliefs about associations) activated the putative dopaminergic midbrain; by contrast, precision-weighted PEs about cue-outcome associations (that update beliefs about volatility) activated the cholinergic basal forebrain. These findings suggested selective dopaminergic and cholinergic influences on precision-weighted PEs at different hierarchical levels.Here, we tested this hypothesis, repeating our fMRI study under pharmacological manipulations in healthy participants. Specifically, we performed two pharmacological fMRI studies with a between-subject double-blind placebo-controlled design: study 1 used antagonists of dopaminergic (amisulpride) and muscarinic (biperiden) receptors, study 2 used enhancing drugs of dopaminergic (levodopa) and cholinergic (galantamine) modulation.Pooled across all pharmacological conditions of study 1 and study 2, respectively, we found that low-level precision-weighted PEs activated the midbrain and high-level precision-weighted PEs the basal forebrain as in our previous study. However, we found pharmacological effects on brain activity associated with these computational quantities only when splitting the precision-weighted PEs into their PE and precision components: in a brainstem region putatively containing cholinergic (pedunculopontine and laterodorsal tegmental) nuclei, biperiden (compared to placebo) enhanced low-level PE responses and attenuated high-level PE activity, while amisulpride reduced high-level PE responses. Additionally, in the putative dopaminergic midbrain, galantamine compared to placebo enhanced low-level PE responses (in a body-weight dependent manner) and amisulpride enhanced high-level precision activity. Task behaviour was not affected by any of the drugs.These results do not support our hypothesis of a clear-cut dichotomy between different hierarchical inference levels and neurotransmitter systems, but suggest a more complex interaction between these neuromodulatory systems and hierarchical Bayesian quantities. However, our present results may have been affected by confounds inherent to pharmacological fMRI. We discuss these confounds and outline improved experimental tests for the future.

Cholinergic modulation of motor sequence learning

Involvement of the Crebellum in Sequential Finger Movement Learning: Evidence from Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Pre-stimulus beta power modulation during motor sequence learning is reduced in 'Parkinson's disease

Motor sequence learning and movement disorders

The cerebellum is involved in implicit motor sequence learning

Cholinergic Modulation of Visual Attention and Working Memory: Dissociable Effects of Basal Forebrain 192-Igg-saporin Lesions and Intraprefrontal Infusions of Scopolamine

Motor sequence learning-induced corticospinal plasticity is biased towards sensorimotor mu rhythm peak phases

Cholinergic and dopaminergic effects on prediction error and uncertainty responses during sensory associative learning

Dissociable Effects of AMPA-induced Lesions of the Vertical Limb Diagonal Band of Broca on Performance of the 5-Choice Serial Reaction Time Task and on Acquisition of a Conditional Visual Discrimination

Attentional Functions of the Forebrain Cholinergic Systems: Effects of Intraventricular Hemicholinium, Physostigmine, Basal Forebrain Lesions and Intracortical Grafts on a Multiple-Choice Serial Reaction Time Task

The left primary motor cortex and cerebellar vermis are critical hubs in bimanual sequential learning

Sequential perceptual learning of letter identification and "uncrowding" in normal peripheral vision: Effects of task, training order, and cholinergic enhancement

Training-related changes in neural beta oscillations associated with implicit and explicit motor sequence learning

Cingulate and cerebellar beta oscillations are engaged in the acquisition of auditory-motor sequences

Motor sequence learning elicits mu peak-specific corticospinal plasticity

Effects of Excitotoxic Lesions of the Septum and Vertical Limb Nucleus of the Diagonal Band of Broca on Conditional Visual Discrimination: Relationship Between Performance and Choline Acetyltransferase Activity in the Cingulate Cortex

Effects of manipulating prefrontal activity and dopamine D1 receptor signaling in an appetitive feature-negative discrimination learning task.

Deep brain stimulation of the ventrointermediate nucleus of the thalamus to treat essential tremor improves motor sequence learning

Cholinergic modulation of rearing in rats performing a spatial memory task

Combined effects of pharmacological interventions and intermittent theta-burst stimulation on motor sequence learning

Effects of training pre-movement sensorimotor rhythms on behavioral performance