Abstract:The relationship between energy barriers, transition-state looseness and 2° α-deuterium kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) has been re-evaluated for a range of identity SN2 methyl transfer reactions that extends to “exploded” transition structures (TSs). Ab initio MP2/6-311+G* molecular orbital calculations have been performed for reactions involving the neutral nucleophiles X = CO, N2, NH3, N(CH3)3, OH2, Kr, Ar, Ne and He, along with anionic nucleophiles X− = F, Cl, Br, CN, NC, CCH, and OH. The behaviour previously noted by Wolfe and co-workers, from MP2/6-31+G* studies of identity and non-identity methyl transfers with anionic nucleophiles and neutral electrophiles only, does not apply to the broader range which also includes neutral nucleophiles and cationic electrophiles: a looser TS is not associated with a higher energy barrier and a more inverse 2° α-D KIE. Moreover, when the interaction of the nucleophile with the electrophile in the reactant complex (RC) is considered, no simple relationships between “looseness” or “tightness” and either energy barriers or KIEs are found. The variation in energy barriers may be understood by means of a simple model involving the distance travelled by the methyl group within the encounter complex from RC to the product complex (PC) and the force constant for stretching the bond to the leaving group in RC. There is a fair linear correlation between the 2° α-D KIE and the change in this same stretching force constant, from RC to TS. The methyl group in the SN2 TS does not resemble an isolated methyl cation, even for systems showing “SN1-like” properties, owing to the significant influence of the nucleophile and leaving group. Consideration of the unusual range of nucleophiles X = Kr, Ar, Ne and He in identity reactions with CH3X+ shows a mechanistic changeover from a double-well potential with a true SN2 TS to a single-well potential with a symmetric intermediate corresponding to a solvated methyl cation.

Nonadditivity of secondary deuterium isotope effects on basicity of trimethylamine

Kinetic isotope effects. Part 5.—Bromination of acetophenone-d3 and inter-relationship between deuterium and tritium isotope effects

H/D isotope effects on NMR chemical shifts of nuclei involved in a hydrogen bridge of hydrogen isocyanide complexes with fluoride anion

Quantum Suppression of Intramolecular Deuterium Kinetic Isotope Effects in a Pericyclic Hydrogen Transfer Reaction.

Strong inverse kinetic isotope effect observed in ammonia charge exchange reactions

Structural isotopic effects in the smallest chiral amino acid: observation of a structural phase transition in fully deuterated alanine

Full-dimensional Quantum Dynamics Study of Isotope Effects for the H2 + NH2/ND2/NHD and H2/D2/HD + NH2 Reactions

Opposite effects of the rotational and translational energy on the rates of ion-molecule reactions near $0\,\text{K}$: the $\text{D}_2^++\text{NH}_3$ and $\text{D}_2^++\text{ND}_3$ reactions

The Effect of Deuteration on the H2 Receptor Histamine Binding Profile: A Computational Insight into Modified Hydrogen Bonding Interactions

In-depth Investigation of the Iodine-Nitrogen Interaction Mechanism Using Ab Initio and Density Functional Theory Calculations

The isotope effect on charge transport for bithiophene and di(n-hexyl)-bithiophene: impacts of deuteration position, deuteration number and side chain substitution position

The isotope effect o n charge tra nsport for bithiophe ne a nd di( n-hexyl)-bithiophe ne: impacts of deuteratio n positio n, deuteratio n number a nd side chai n substitutio n positio n

Deuterated forms of H${_3^+}$ and their importance in astrochemistry

Theoretical Study of the Isotope Effect in Optical Rotation

KINETIC DEUTERIUM ISOTOPE EFFECT IN THE REACTION OF METHYL IODIDE WITH THIOSULFATE ION IN AQUEOUS SOLUTION.

Kinetic isotope effects for gas phase SN2 methyl transfer: a computational study of anionic and cationic identity reactions

Geometric isotope effect of deuteration in a hydrogen-bonded host–guest crystal

The H-D-isotope effect of heavy water affecting ligand-mediated nanoparticle formation in SANS and NMR experiments

H/D isotope effect on porphine and porphycene molecules with multicomponent hybrid density functional theory

Deuterium enrichment of ammonia produced by surface N+H/D addition reactions at low temperature

Isotope Effect on Fractional Dilatability of Solute Water as an Indicator of the H-Bonding Ability of an Aprotic Dipolar Solvent