Abstract:INTRODUCTION: Serotonin syndrome (toxicity) describes adverse drug effects from toxic amounts of intra-synaptic central nervous system serotonin. A wide range of drugs have been implicated to cause serotonin toxicity, not all justifiably. The plausible agents all have a final common pathway resulting in a substantial increase in central nervous system serotonergic neurotransmission. Serotonin toxicity is characterized by neuromuscular excitation, mental status changes, and autonomic dysregulation. Signs and symptoms represent a spectrum of toxicity (mild to life-threatening) related to increasing serotonin concentrations. As there is no consensus on the threshold for "toxicity" or diagnostic criteria, the true incidence of serotonin toxicity is unknown. The incidence in overdose is easier to quantify and is reasonably common in serotonergic antidepressant overdoses. In a large case series of overdoses, moderate serotonin toxicity occurred in 14% of poisonings with a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor. While half those ingesting a monoamine oxidase inhibitor in combination with a serotonergic agent in overdose exhibit at least moderately severe serotonin toxicity. In contrast, the incidence of serotonin toxicity in those on therapeutic serotonergic agents appears to be very low.OBJECTIVES: To provide a narrative review of the current diagnostic criteria, utilizing case reports of fatalities to evaluate how many meet the various diagnostic criteria and propose practical solutions to resolve controversies in diagnosis.METHODS: A review of serotonin toxicity diagnostic criteria in the English literature was completed by searching Embase and PubMed from January 1990 to July 2021 for the keywords "serotonin syndrome/toxicity" paired with "diagnostic criteria" or "diagnosis." Also, fatal cases of serotonin toxicity identified from a recent systematic review were independently examined to determine what diagnostic criteria were met and whether serotonin toxicity or another cause was most likely.REVIEW OF DIAGNOSIS CRITERIA: Serotonin toxicity is a clinical diagnosis, four diagnostic criteria (Sternbach, Serotonin Syndrome Scale, Radomski, and Hunter) have been proposed. However, the Serotonin Syndrome Scale has not been validated in patients with serotonin toxicity and only utilized in those on a serotonergic agent. The remaining three criteria are utilized more widely but have undergone little refinement or validation.REVIEW OF FATAL CASES: Shortfalls with diagnostic criteria can be illustrated by examining case fatalities. Of 55 fatal cases reviewed, 12 (22%) were unlikely to be serotonin toxicity. Sternbach and Radomski criteria were met by 25 (45%), 20 (36%) had insufficient data reported and 10 (18%) met an exclusion criterion. Few had sufficient information reported to determine whether Hunter Criteria were met, with only 13 (24%) documented as meeting the criteria, the remaining 42 (76%) had insufficient data.RESOLVING SHORTFALLS IN CURRENT DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA: As serotonin toxicity is a clinical diagnosis, issues arise when basing the diagnosis on symptom criteria alone, without considering whether the drug/s ingested increase central nervous system serotonin or whether there is an alternative diagnosis. This has resulted in case reports and government warnings for drugs that cannot plausibly cause significant serotonin toxicity (e.g., ondansetron and antipsychotics). We propose when assessing for a serotonin toxidrome, both the causative agent(s) and clinical scenario is considered to determine the likelihood of serotonin toxicity. Then the clinical features assessed, those with a moderate to high prior probability (e.g., serotonergic drug-drug interaction, overdose, recent initiation or increase in dose of serotonergic agent/s) could be diagnosed based on the Hunter criteria. However, those with a low probability (e.g., stable therapeutic doses of a serotonergic agent) require more specific and stringent criteria. Finally, we propose a minimum dataset for case reports/series of serotonin toxicity.CONCLUSIONS: More complete and accurate reporting of serotonin toxicity cases is required in the future, to avoid further misleading associations that are physiologically implausible.

Antibiotic-induced serotonin syndrome

Serotonin Syndrome: An Emerging Reality in the Emergency Department

Serotonin syndrome: An often-neglected medical emergency

Serotonergic Medication Error: A Case Report of Serotonin Syndrome

A case of serotonin syndrome caused by venlafaxine and lithium

An atypical case of serotonin syndrome with normal dose of selective serotonin inhibitors: A case report.

Serotonin Syndrome Following Low-Dose Sertraline: A Case Report

Recognizing serotonin syndrome in the intensive care unit: a case report of serotonin syndrome in a patient taking amitriptyline, buprenorphine, pregabalin, and fentanyl

Lithium and venlafaxine interaction: a case of serotonin syndrome

Fluoxetine and the serotonin syndrome

An Unexpected Presentation of Serotonin Syndrome in a Patient Receiving ECT

Coexistence of serotonin syndrome and neuroleptic malignant syndrome: does it exist?

A case of the serotonin syndrome secondary to phenelzine monotherapy at therapeutic dosing

Possible Sertraline-Induced Extrapyramidal Adverse Effects in an Adolescent.

The serotonin toxidrome: shortfalls of current diagnostic criteria for related syndromes

A Case Report on Serotonin Syndrome in a Patient With Parkinson's Disease: Diagnostic and Management Challenges

Posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome in a patient with serotonin syndrome

Serotonin syndrome during treatment with low dose of escitalopram associated with miconazole mucoadhesive tablet: a suspected drug interaction

A Case study of polypharmacy-induced serotonin syndrome in a cancer patient

Patterns of SSRI Exposures Reported to the U.S. Poison Centers

Serotonin syndrome caused by escitalopram in Parkinson's disease psychosis: a case report