Experiences of Frontline Managers during the COVID-19 Pandemic: Recommendations for Organizational Resilience

Sonia Udod,Pamela Baxter,Suzanne Gagnon,Gayle Halas,Saba Raja

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/healthcare12030407

2024-02-05

Health Care

Abstract:The COVID-19 pandemic caused a global health crisis directly impacting the healthcare system. Healthcare leaders influence and shape the ability of an organization to cope with and recover from a crisis such as the COVID-19 pandemic. Their actions serve to guide and support nurses' actions through unpredictable health service demands. The purpose of this paper was to examine frontline managers' experiences and organizational leadership responses that activated organizational resilience during the COVID-19 pandemic, and to learn for ongoing and future responses to healthcare crises. Fourteen managers participated in semi-structured interviews. We found that: (1) leadership challenges (physical resources and emotional burden), (2) the influence of senior leader decision-making on managers (constant change, shortage of human resources, adapting care delivery, and cooperation and collaboration), and (3) lessons learned (managerial caring behaviours and role modelling, adaptive leadership, education and training, culture of care for self, and others) were evidence of managers' responses to the crisis. Overall, the study provides evidence of managers experiences during the early waves of the pandemic in supporting nurses and fostering organizational resilience. Knowing manager's experiences can facilitate planning, preparing, and strengthening their leadership strategies to improve work conditions is a high priority to manage and sustain nurses' mental health and wellbeing.

health care sciences & services,health policy & services

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily discusses the experiences of frontline managers during the COVID-19 pandemic and how they activated organizational resilience in times of crisis. The research aims to understand the challenges faced by frontline managers in responding to COVID-19, the impact of senior leadership decisions, and the lessons learned for future medical crises through semi-structured interviews.

The paper points out that frontline managers faced challenges during the pandemic, including resource shortages (both physical and emotional), frequent changes in senior decision-making, manpower shortages, adjustments to nursing models, collaboration and cooperation issues, etc. They need to adapt to the constantly changing environment while also prioritizing the mental health of their employees. The research also emphasizes the importance of leadership in times of crisis, including creating psychological safety, demonstrating empathy, adaptive leadership, and fostering a culture of self-care and care for others.

Through interviews with 14 frontline managers, the research identified three key themes: leadership challenges, the impact of senior decision-making on managers, and lessons learned. These lessons include caring behaviors of management, role modeling, adaptive leadership, education and training, a culture of self-care and care for others, and the importance of organizational resilience.

The results of the paper show that all participants were females with extensive management experience. The study revealed the difficulties faced by leaders in the early stages of the pandemic, such as resource shortages and emotional stress, as well as the impact of senior decision-making on the work of managers. Additionally, it presents the experiences and lessons learned from the crisis, such as how to better support employees, enhance organizational resilience, and prepare for future crises.

In conclusion, this paper aims to provide a basis for improving working conditions, strengthening leadership strategies, and maintaining and enhancing the mental health and well-being of healthcare workers by understanding and analyzing the experiences of frontline managers during the COVID-19 period.