Robust Tests for Convergence Clubs

Luisa Corrado,Melvyn Weeks,Thanasis Stengos,M. Ege Yazgan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1812.09518
2018-12-22
Abstract:In many applications common in testing for convergence the number of cross-sectional units is large and the number of time periods are few. In these situations asymptotic tests based on an omnibus null hypothesis are characterised by a number of problems. In this paper we propose a multiple pairwise comparisons method based on an a recursive bootstrap to test for convergence with no prior information on the composition of convergence clubs. Monte Carlo simulations suggest that our bootstrap-based test performs well to correctly identify convergence clubs when compared with other similar tests that rely on asymptotic arguments. Across a potentially large number of regions, using both cross-country and regional data for the European Union, we find that the size distortion which afflicts standard tests and results in a bias towards finding less convergence, is ameliorated when we utilise our bootstrap test.
Econometrics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the bias problem caused by the small sample size in the standard test methods when detecting regional economic convergence. Specifically, when dealing with data sets with a large number of cross - sectional units but a short time series, asymptotic test methods based on the overall null hypothesis tend to produce size distortion, leading to an underestimation of the existence of convergence. This bias can mislead policymakers into believing that more policy interventions are required to promote the convergence of income or output among regions, when in fact such a large number of interventions may not be necessary. To overcome this problem, the author proposes a multi - pair comparison method based on the recursive bootstrap method for testing convergence without pre - determining the composition of convergence clubs. Through this method, the author aims to more accurately identify which regions form convergence clubs, thereby providing a more reliable basis for policy - making. Monte Carlo simulations show that, compared with other similar tests relying on asymptotic theory, the proposed bootstrap - based test method performs well in correctly identifying convergence clubs.