Stellar mid-life crisis: subcritical magnetic dynamos of solar-like stars and the breakdown of gyrochronology

Bindesh Tripathi,Dibyendu Nandy,Soumitro Banerjee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnrasl/slab035

2021-07-29

Abstract:Recent observations reveal the surprising breakdown of stellar gyrochronology relations at about the Sun's age hinting that middle-aged, solar-like stars transition to a magnetically inactive future. We provide a theoretical basis for these intriguing observations inspired by simulations with a mathematical dynamo model that can explore long-term solar cycle fluctuations. We reproduce the observed bimodal distribution of sunspot numbers, but only for subcritical dynamos. Based on a bifurcation analysis, we argue that ageing of solar-like stars makes the magnetically-weak dynamo regime readily accessible. Weak magnetic field production in this regime compromises wind-driven angular momentum losses thus disrupting the hegemony of magnetic braking on stellar rotational spin-down. This hypothesis of {\emph{subcritical magnetic dynamos}} of solar-like stars provides a self-consistent, unifying physical basis for a diversity of solar-stellar phenomena such as why stars beyond their mid-life do not spin-down as fast as in their youth, the break-down of stellar gyrochronology relations, the observed bimodal distribution of long-term sunspot observations and recent findings suggesting that the Sun may be transitioning to a magnetically inactive future.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the weakening of magnetic activity in solar - like stars in the middle of their life cycle, especially how this phenomenon affects the relationship between the rotation rate and age of stars (i.e., the failure of the stellar gyrochronology relationship). Specifically, the paper explores the mechanism by which middle - aged solar - like stars transition from a magnetically active state to a magnetically inactive state. This transition leads to a weakened magnetic braking effect on the stellar rotation deceleration, which in turn affects the reliability of inferring the age of a star based on its rotation rate.

The paper explains these observational phenomena by proposing a theoretical basis, which is based on the assumption that the dynamo mechanism of solar - like stars changes from a super - critical state to a sub - critical state when they are approaching the middle of their lives. The dynamo in the sub - critical state generates a weaker magnetic field, which reduces the angular momentum loss driven by the magnetic field, thus disrupting the dominant role of magnetic braking in the deceleration of stellar rotation. This assumption can not only explain why stars older than middle - aged do not decelerate their rotation as rapidly as when they were young, but also explain the failure of the stellar gyrochronology relationship, the bimodal distribution of long - term sunspot observations, and the recent research indicating that the sun may be transitioning towards a magnetically inactive future.