Abstract:Based on the Riemannian manifold model, we study the asymptotic behavior of a widely applied unsupervised learning algorithm, locally linear embedding (LLE), when the point cloud is sampled from a compact, smooth manifold with boundary. We show several peculiar behaviors of LLE near the boundary that are different from those diffusion-based algorithms. In particular, we show that LLE pointwisely converges to a mixed-type differential operator with degeneracy and we calculate the convergence rate. The impact of the hyperbolic part of the operator is discussed and we propose a clipped LLE algorithm which is a potential approach to recover the Dirichlet Laplace-Beltrami operator.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?
The paper "WHEN LOCALLY LINEAR EMBEDDING HITS BOUNDARY" mainly studies the asymptotic behavior of the Locally Linear Embedding (LLE) algorithm when data points are sampled from a compact smooth manifold with a boundary. Specifically, the authors explore the following problems:
1. **The behavior of the LLE algorithm near the boundary**:
- The authors show some strange behaviors of LLE near the manifold boundary, which are different from diffusion - based algorithms (such as diffusion maps).
- In particular, they prove that LLE converges point - by - point to a degenerate mixed - type differential operator and calculate the convergence rate.
2. **The influence of the boundary on LLE**:
- The authors study the situation where the asymptotic operator corresponding to LLE involves singular coefficients when the manifold has a boundary.
- Through the example of one - dimensional manifolds, they relate the eigenvalue problem of LLE to the Sturm - Liouville equation.
3. **Improving the LLE algorithm to recover the Dirichlet Laplace - Beltrami operator**:
- The authors propose a "clipped LLE" algorithm. By clipping certain points near the boundary to eliminate the influence of the hyperbolic part, it is expected to recover the Laplace - Beltrami operator with Dirichlet boundary conditions.
4. **Comparison between LLE and diffusion maps (DM)**:
- The authors compare the behavioral differences between LLE and DM on the boundary and explain the differences between them in handling boundary data.
5. **Numerical simulation and theoretical analysis**:
- Through a series of numerical simulations, the effectiveness of the clipped LLE algorithm is verified, and the influence of the hyperbolic part on the operator is further explored.
### Key conclusions
- **Convergence properties**: LLE converges point - by - point to a degenerate mixed - type differential operator near the boundary.
- **Clipped LLE**: The clipped LLE algorithm can potentially recover the Laplace - Beltrami operator with Dirichlet boundary conditions.
- **Boundary effect**: The special behavior of LLE near the boundary is different from that of manifolds without boundaries and is significantly different from other algorithms such as diffusion maps.
### Formula representation
The formulas involved in the paper are represented in Markdown format as follows:
- **Definition of the LLE matrix**:
\[
W_{ki} =
\begin{cases}
w_k(j) & \text{if } z_i = z_{k,j} \in N_k \\
0 & \text{otherwise}
\end{cases}
\]
- **Local covariance matrix**:
\[
C_x := \mathbb{E}\left[(\iota(X) - \iota(x))(\iota(X) - \iota(x))^T \chi_{B_\varepsilon^{\mathbb{R}^p}(\iota(x))}(\iota(X))\right] \in \mathbb{R}^{p \times p}
\]
- **Augmented vector**:
\[
T(x)^T = \mathbb{E}\left[(\iota(X) - \iota(x)) \chi_{B_\varepsilon^{\mathbb{R}^p}(\iota(x))}(\iota(X))\right]^T U_x I_{p,r} (\Lambda_x + \varepsilon^{d+3} I_{p \times p})^{-1} U_x^T \in \mathbb{R}^p
\]
Through these studies, the authors provide new perspectives and methods for understanding and improving the LLE algorithm, especially when dealing with manifold data with boundaries.