Abstract:Around seven-in-ten Americans use social media (SM) to connect and engage, making these platforms excellent sources of information to understand human behavior and other problems relevant to social sciences. While the presence of a behavior can be detected, it is unclear who or under what circumstances the behavior was generated. Despite the large sample sizes of SM datasets, they almost always come with significant biases, some of which have been studied before. Here, we hypothesize the presence of a largely unrecognized form of bias on SM platforms, called participation bias , that is distinct from selection bias. It is defined as the skew in the demographics of the participants who opt-in to discussions of the topic, compared to the demographics of the underlying SM platform. To infer the participant's demographics, we propose a novel generative probabilistic framework that links surveys and SM data at the granularity of demographic subgroups (and not individuals). Our method is distinct from existing approaches that elicit such information at the individual level using their profile name, images, and other metadata, thus infringing upon their privacy. We design a statistical simulation to simulate multiple SM platforms and a diverse range of topics to validate the model's estimates in different scenarios. We use Twitter data as a case study to demonstrate participation bias on the topic of gun violence delineated by political party affiliation and gender. Although Twitter's user population leans Democratic and has an equal number of men and women according to Pew, our model's estimates point to the presence of participation bias on the topic of gun control in the opposite direction, with slightly more Republicans than Democrats, and more men compared to women. Our study cautions that in the rush to use digital data for decision-making and understanding public opinions, we must account for the biases inherent in how SM data are produced, lest we may also arrive at biased inferences about the public.

Opinion Formation Threshold Estimates from Different Combinations of Social Media Data-Types

The Investigation of Social Media Data Thresholds for Opinion Formation

Opinion Formation and the Collective Dynamics of Risk Perception

Opinion Formation on Social Media Platform

Measuring receptivity to misinformation at scale on a social media platform

Social Influence and the Collective Dynamics of Opinion Formation

The generation and regulation of public opinion on multiplex social networks

A multilayered graph-based framework to explore behavioural phenomena in social media conversations

Social Media Public Opinion as Flocks in a Murmuration: Conceptualizing and Measuring Opinion Expression on Social Media

Quantifying Information Overload in Social Media and its Impact on Social Contagions

Inference in Opinion Dynamics under Social Pressure

Modelling opinion dynamics under the impact of influencer and media strategies

Measuring relative opinion from location-based social media: A case study of the 2016 U.S. presidential election

Quantifying participation biases on social media

Learning From Aggregated Opinion

Mass media impact on opinion evolution in biased digital environments: a bounded confidence model

Competitive Influence Minimization in Multi-Group Social Networks: An Opinion - Based Solution

Opinion formation by belief propagation: A heuristic to identify low-credible sources of information

Opinion dynamics in social networks under the influence of mass media

Finding the Tipping Point: When Heterogeneous Evaluations in Social Media Converge and Influence Organizational Legitimacy

Social media battle for attention: opinion dynamics on competing networks