Time to Stop Telling Biophysics Students that Light is Primarily a Wave

Philip C. Nelson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpj.2017.12.036
2018-09-15
Abstract:Standard pedagogy introduces optics as though it were a consequence of Maxwell's equations, and only grudgingly admits, usually in a rushed aside, that light has a particulate character that can somehow be reconciled with the wave picture. Recent revolutionary advances in optical imaging, however, make this approach more and more unhelpful: How are we to describe two-photon imaging, FRET, localization microscopy, and a host of related techniques to students who think of light primarily as a wave? I was surprised to find that everything I wanted my biophysics students to know about light, including image formation, x-ray diffraction, and even Bessel beams, could be expressed as well (or better) from the quantum viewpoint pioneered by Richard Feynman. Even my undergraduate students grasp this viewpoint as well as (or better than) the traditional one, and by mid-semester they are already well positioned to integrate the latest advances into their understanding. Moreover, I have found that this approach clarifies my own understanding of new techniques.
Other Quantitative Biology,Biological Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in biophysics teaching, traditionally, the introduction of light is mainly based on the wave theory, which makes it difficult for students to understand the working principles of modern optical imaging techniques (such as two - photon imaging, FRET, localization microscopy, etc.). The author believes that the traditional teaching methods have failed to fully explain the particle characteristics of light, and this characteristic is crucial for understanding the above - mentioned modern techniques. Therefore, the paper proposes a new teaching method. Starting from the perspective of quantum mechanics, it first emphasizes the particle nature of light and then introduces the wave nature, in order to help students better understand and master these advanced biophysical techniques. Specifically, the paper points out: 1. **Limitations of traditional teaching methods**: When introducing light, most textbooks usually start from Maxwell's equations and regard light as a wave phenomenon, only briefly mentioning the particle nature of light. This teaching method leads to students' incomplete understanding of light, especially when facing modern optical imaging techniques, which often rely on the particle nature of light. 2. **Advantages of the new teaching method**: The author suggests introducing the particle nature of light to students from the very first day and strengthening this point through experimental observations (such as the photoelectric effect, single - photon detection, etc.). This method can not only enable students to better understand the basic nature of light, but also help them master modern biophysical techniques more quickly. 3. **Practical applications**: Through this new teaching method, students can more intuitively understand phenomena such as fluorescence imaging, two - photon excitation, and resonance energy transfer, thus laying a solid foundation for their actual operations in the laboratory. In short, this paper aims to enable students to better adapt to and understand advanced techniques and concepts in modern biophysics by changing the teaching method of light.