Abstract:figure legend Physiological selection is shown as a series of causes and effects. An environmental change causes epigenetic responses in a large fraction of the population. A given epigenetic effect may have the direct or indirect consequence of impacting reproduction or fertility, such as by changing mating behaviour or post‐zygotic compatibility. If this effect on reproduction is positively discriminate, meaning exhibits some reference of like‐with‐like, either by trait‐bearing organisms differentially reproducing with other trait‐bearing organisms, or less‐so with non‐trait‐bearing organisms, then the population will begin to diverge into sub‐species with different phenotypes. A chance mutation affecting a single or extremely few individuals in a continuous population will be quickly diluted through interbreeding. Charles Darwin fully appreciated this difficulty with relying on natural selection alone, and suggested an enabling role for geographical isolation in the origin of species. However, Darwin also believed in evolution by the inheritance of acquired traits and in populations of interbreeding animals, both of which would need a different isolating mechanism to overcome dilution and play a role in animal evolution. Historically disputed, the inheritance of acquired characters is now increasingly accepted as a phenomenon, and Charles Darwin himself is acknowledged as closely pre‐empting the type of physiology necessary to mediate it in his hypothesis of 'pangenesis'. In this article, we question how the inheritance of acquired traits might overcome the problem of dilution by interbreeding and contribute to evolution. Specifically, we describe how Darwin's young protégé, George Romanes, developed ideas he discussed with Darwin and extended pangenesis to include a conceivable solution published after Darwin's death: physiological selection of fertility. In light of the 'rediscovery' of pangenesis, here we recount physiological selection as a testable hypothesis to explain how environmentally acquired characteristics could become coupled to the generation of species.

The genomic consequences of selection across development

A multidimensional selective landscape drives adaptive divergence between and within closely related Phlox species

Gene expression and alternative splicing contribute to adaptive divergence of ecotypes

Variation in Resource Environment Drives Adaptive Divergence in Drosophila melanogaster

Is speciation an unrelenting march to reproductive isolation?

The genomic landscape of adaptation to a new host plant

Selection of p53 pathway in adaptive evolution and reproductive isolation in incipient sympatric speciation of Drosophila at Evolution Canyon

A cosmopolitan inversion facilitates seasonal adaptation in overwintering Drosophila

How weedy dominated the world: ancestral variation and polygenic adaptation

Speciation and the developmental alarm clock

Inversions contribute disproportionately to parallel genomic divergence in dune sunflowers

Speciation by physiological selection of environmentally acquired traits

Evolved and plastic gene expression in adaptation to a novel niche

Adaptation with gene flow across the landscape in a dune sunflower

Allopatric speciation in cattails: Genomic landscapes of divergence across spp. suggest balancing selection, introgressions, and the absence of adaptive divergence

Gravitropic Gene Expression Divergence Associated With Adaptation to Contrasting Environments in an Australian Wildflower

Gene expression divergence between locally adapted inland annual and coastal perennial ecotypes of Mimulus guttatus across developmental stages

Pervasive fitness trade-offs revealed by rapid adaptation in large experimental populations of Drosophila melanogaster

The evolution and fate of diversity under hard and soft selection

Scattered differentiation of unlinked loci across the genome underlines ecological divergence of the selfing grass Brachypodium stacei

Clines on the seashore: The genomic architecture underlying rapid divergence in the face of gene flow