SME investment best strategies. Outliers for assessing how to optimize performance

Marcel Ausloos,Roy Cerqueti,Francesca Bartolacci,Nicola G. Castellano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physa.2018.06.039

2018-06-13

Abstract:Any research on strategies for reaching business excellence aims at revealing the appropriate course of actions any executive should consider. Thus, discussions take place on how effective a performance measurement system can be estimated, or/and validated. Can one find an adequate measure (i) on the performance result due to whatever level of investment, and (ii) on the timing of such investments? We argue that extreme value statistics provide the answer. We demonstrate that the level and timing of investments allow to be forecasting small and medium size enterprises (SME) performance, - at financial crisis times. The "investment level" is taken as the yearly total tangible asset (TTA). The financial/economic performance indicators defining growth are the sales or total assets variations; profitability is defined from returns on investments or returns on sales. Companies on the Italian Stock Exchange STAR Market serve as example. It is found from the distributions extreme values that outlier companies (with positive performance) are those with the lowest but growing TTA. In contrast, the SME with low TTA, but which did not increase its TTA, before the crisis, became a negative outlier. The outcome of these statistical findings should suggest strategies to SME board members.

General Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the issue of how small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) can improve their performance during economic crises by optimizing their investment strategies. Specifically, the paper explores the following key issues:

1. **Impact of Investment Levels and Timing**: The paper examines the impact of different investment levels (measured by Total Tangible Assets, TTA) and investment timing on the performance of SMEs. In particular, it explores how changes in investment before and after an economic crisis affect the growth and profitability of enterprises.

2. **Application of Extreme Value Statistics**: The paper utilizes extreme value statistical methods to identify and analyze companies with abnormal performance. These outliers (i.e., "positive outliers" and "negative outliers") provide important information about successful and failed investment strategies.

3. **Effectiveness of Performance Measurement Systems**: The paper evaluates the effectiveness and reliability of existing performance measurement systems during economic crises and proposes suggestions for improvement.

4. **Strategic Recommendations**: Based on the results of statistical analysis, the paper provides specific strategic recommendations for SME board members to help them better cope with challenges during economic crises.

Overall, this paper aims to reveal how SMEs can improve their performance during economic crises through reasonable investment strategies by using statistical analysis methods.