Resource Logics with a Diminishing Resource

Natasha Alechina,Brian Logan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1806.11559

2018-06-24

Abstract:Model-checking resource logics with production and consumption of resources is a computationally hard and often undecidable problem. We introduce a simple and realistic assumption that there is at least one diminishing resource, that is, a resource that cannot be produced and every action has a non-zero cost on this resource. An example of such resource is time. We show that, with this assumption, problems that are undecidable even for the underlying Alternating Time Temporal Logic, such as model-checking under imperfect information and perfect recall, become decidable for resource logics with a diminishing resource.

Logic in Computer Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the model - checking problem in resource logics, especially in the presence of diminishing resources. Specifically, the paper introduces an assumption that there is at least one non - renewable resource, and each action incurs a non - zero cost on this resource. Time is a typical example. Through this assumption, the paper shows that even some originally undecidable problems in the basic Alternating Time Temporal Logic (ATL), such as model - checking under incomplete information and perfect recall conditions, become decidable.

### Main Contributions of the Paper

1. **Introduction of the Diminishing - Resource Assumption**:
- The paper proposes a simple assumption that there is at least one diminishing resource in the system, which cannot be produced and each action incurs a non - zero cost on it. Time is a typical example.

2. **Improvement in Decidability**:
- Under this assumption, some originally undecidable problems (such as model - checking under incomplete information and perfect recall conditions) become decidable. This includes the model - checking problem in resource logics.

3. **Algorithm and Complexity Analysis**:
- The paper proposes model - checking algorithms for resource logics with diminishing resources (such as RB±ATL#), and analyzes the complexity of these algorithms. For example, for RB±ATL#, the model - checking problem is PSPACE - solvable when the resource bounds are represented in unary.
- For RB±ATL# with incomplete information and perfect recall, the paper also provides new model - checking algorithms and upper bounds on complexity.

4. **Extension to Other Logics**:
- The paper also defines the Resource - Agent Logic with diminishing resources (RAL#), and provides the corresponding model - checking algorithms, proving that its complexity is the same as that of RB±ATL#.

### Technical Details

- **Resource Consumption and Production**:
- Each action consumes or produces resources, but diminishing resources (such as time) are always consumed and cannot be produced.
- The existence of diminishing resources makes all strategies bounded, even if unbounded production is allowed for other resource types.

- **Model - Checking Algorithm**:
- The paper proposes a depth - first - search - based model - checking algorithm, using a search tree to record the search state.
- The algorithm needs to handle multi - step strategies and ensure the uniformity of strategies under incomplete information conditions.

- **Complexity Analysis**:
- By limiting the depth of the search tree and the storage space, the paper proves that the model - checking problem is PSPACE - or EXPTIME - solvable in some cases.

### Conclusion

By introducing the assumption of diminishing resources, the paper successfully solves some important problems in resource logics, especially those model - checking problems under incomplete information and perfect recall conditions. These results are not only theoretically significant but also provide new tools and methods for resource management and verification in practical applications.