The Stock Market Has Grown Unstable Since February 2018

Blake C. Stacey,Yaneer Bar-Yam

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1806.00529

2018-06-02

Abstract:On the fifth of February, 2018, the Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped 1,175.21 points, the largest single-day fall in history in raw point terms. This followed a 666-point loss on the second, and another drop of over a thousand points occurred three days later. It is natural to ask whether these events indicate a transition to a new regime of market behavior, particularly given the dramatic fluctuations --- both gains and losses --- in the weeks since. To illuminate this matter, we can apply a model grounded in the science of complex systems, a model that demonstrated considerable success at unraveling the stock-market dynamics from the 1980s through the 2000s. By using large-scale comovement of stock prices as an early indicator of unhealthy market dynamics, this work found that abrupt drops in a certain parameter $U$ provide an early warning of single-day panics and economic crises. Decreases in $U$ indicate regimes of "high co-movement", a market behavior that is not the same as volatility, though market volatility can be a component of co-movement. Applying the same analysis to stock-price data from the beginning of 2016 until now, we find that the $U$ value for the period since 5 February is significantly lower than for the period before. This decrease entered the "danger zone" in the last week of May, 2018.

Statistical Finance,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Did the sharp fluctuations in the stock market on and after February 5, 2018 mark the entry of market behavior into a new, unhealthy phase?**

Specifically, the authors focused on:

- **On February 5, 2018, the Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped 1,175.21 points in a single day**, which was one of the largest single - day declines in history.
- Before and after this, the stock market also experienced multiple large - scale fluctuations, including a 666 - point loss on February 2 and another thousand - point plunge a few days later.
- Do these events indicate a fundamental change in market behavior, especially considering the sharp fluctuations (both upward and downward) in the following weeks?

To answer these questions, the authors applied a model based on complex - system science. This model has achieved remarkable success in analyzing the stock market dynamics from the 1980s to the 2000s. They specifically focused on a parameter \( U \), which is used to measure the "co - movement" of the market. A sudden drop in the \( U \) value is used as an early - warning signal for market panic and economic crises.

By analyzing stock price data from the beginning of 2016 to the end of May 2018, the authors found that the \( U \) value after February 5, 2018 was significantly lower than the previous level and entered the "danger zone" in late May 2018. This indicates that the market may already be in an unhealthy state and is vulnerable to external shocks.

Therefore, the core issue of this paper is to assess the current health of the market and explore whether this situation will increase the risk of a major market crisis in the future.