Abstract:Differences between men and women have intrigued generations of social scientists, who have found that the two sexes behave differently in settings requiring competition, risk taking, altruism, honesty, as well as many others. Yet, little is known about whether there are gender differences in cooperative behavior. Previous evidence is mixed and inconclusive. Here I shed light on this topic by analyzing the totality of studies that my research group has conducted since 2013. This is a dataset of 10,951 observations coming from 7,322 men and women living in the US, recruited through Amazon Mechanical Turk, and who passed four comprehension questions to make sure they understand the cooperation problem (a one-shot prisoner's dilemma). The analysis demonstrates that women are more cooperative than men. The effect size is small (about 4 percentage points, and this might explain why previous studies failed to detect it) but highly significant (p<.0001).
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Does gender difference affect cooperative behavior, especially performance in the one - shot prisoner's dilemma game?**
### Background and Problem Statement
Social scientists have long been interested in the behavioral differences between men and women. Existing research has shown that in multiple areas such as competition, risk - taking, altruism, and honesty, the two genders exhibit different behavioral patterns. However, regarding gender differences in cooperative behavior, the existing research results are inconsistent and the conclusions are ambiguous.
Cooperative behavior refers to the behavior in which an individual pays a certain cost for others or a group in exchange for greater benefits and expects the other party to take the same action. This behavior is considered a very important part of human social interaction. Therefore, it is of great significance to understand whether gender differences affect cooperative behavior.
### Research Purpose
This article aims to explore whether gender differences will lead to different performances in cooperative behavior by analyzing a large amount of online experimental data (more than 10,000 observation samples). Specifically, the author hopes to verify the following hypotheses:
- Are women more inclined to cooperate than men?
- If there are differences, what is the effect size?
- Why did previous studies fail to consistently detect this difference?
### Method
The author used the one - shot anonymous prisoner's dilemma game as a research tool and recruited 7,322 American participants (including men and women) through the Amazon Mechanical Turk platform. Each participant was required to answer a series of questions to ensure that they understood the essence of the cooperation problem. Then, the author analyzed the cooperation choices of these participants and evaluated the impact of gender on cooperative behavior through linear regression models and meta - analysis.
### Results
Data analysis shows that the cooperation rate of women is slightly higher than that of men (49.7% vs 45.2%). Although the effect is small (about 4 percentage points), it is highly statistically significant (p < 0.0001). In addition, the meta - analysis results show that the overall effect size is 0.036 (95% CI [0.015, 0.057], z = 3.41, p = 0.001), which further supports the conclusion that women are more cooperative than men.
### Conclusion
This study shows that although the impact of gender differences on cooperative behavior is small, there are indeed significant differences, that is, women are more inclined to cooperate than men. This finding helps to explain why previous studies failed to consistently detect this difference (possibly due to insufficient sample size). Future research should further explore the stability of this difference in different cultural backgrounds and social situations, as well as its potential theoretical mechanisms and practical impacts.
### Formula Summary
- **Effect Size**: \[ \text{Effect Size} = 0.036 \]
- **Confidence Interval**: \[ 95\% \, \text{CI} = [0.015, 0.057] \]
- **Z - value**: \[ z = 3.41 \]
- **P - value**: \[ p = 0.001 \]
These formulas are used to describe the statistical significance and effect size of the impact of gender differences on cooperative behavior.