The Generalized Haldane (GH) model tracking population size changes and resolving paradoxes of genetic drift
Yongsen Ruan,Xiaopei Wang,Mei Hou,Wenjie Diao,Miles E. Tracy,Shuhua Xu,Haijun Wen,Chung-I Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.02.19.581083
2024-12-26
Abstract:Population genetic models, such as the Wright-Fisher (WF) model, track relative gene frequencies. The absolute gene copy number, or population size (N), is supplied externally for tracking genetic drift. JBS Haldane (1927) proposed an alternative model based on the branching process, whereby each gene copy is transmitted to K descendants with the mean and variance of E(K) and V(K). In this model, E(K) governs N, while V(K)/N governs genetic drift. Nevertheless, as the branching process allows N to drift unboundedly, a Generalized Haldane (GH) model that regulates N more tightly is proposed. The GH model can account for several paradoxes of molecular evolution. Notably, genetic drift may often become stronger as N becomes larger in the ecological setting, thus contradicting the general view. In particular, a very small population growing exponentially experiences little drift. Interestingly, when the population grows and N oscillates near the carrying capacity, the paradoxical trend is also observed in both field works and laboratory experiments. This paradox whereby population size in genetics (Ne) and ecology (N) could be negatively correlated is resolved by the GH model. Additional paradoxes include ii) The two sexes experiencing drift differently; iii) Genetic drift of advantageous mutations being independent of N; iv) Multi-copy gene systems (viruses, mitochondria, etc.) having no definable Ne (for effective N). In brief, the GH model defines genetic drift simply as V(K), or V(K)/N averaged over the population. It represents an attempt at integrating genetical and ecological analyses into one framework.
Evolutionary Biology