Abstract:In mutualistic associations two species cooperate by exchanging goods or services with members of another species for their mutual benefit. At the same time competition for reproduction primarily continues with members of their own species. In intra-species interactions the prisoner's dilemma is the leading mathematical metaphor to study the evolution of cooperation. Here we consider inter-species interactions in the spatial prisoner's dilemma, where members of each species reside on one lattice layer. Cooperators provide benefits to neighbouring members of the other species at a cost to themselves. Hence, interactions occur across layers but competition remains within layers. We show that rich and complex dynamics unfold when varying the cost-to-benefit ratio of cooperation, r. Four distinct dynamical domains emerge that are separated by critical phase transitions, each characterized by diverging fluctuations in the frequency of cooperation: (i) for large r cooperation is too costly and defection dominates; (ii) for lower r cooperators survive at equal frequencies in both species; (iii) lowering r further results in an intriguing, spontaneous symmetry breaking of cooperation between species with increasing asymmetry for decreasing r; (iv) finally, for small r, bursts of mutual defection appear that increase in size with decreasing r and eventually drive the populations into absorbing states. Typically one species is cooperating and the other defecting and hence establish perfect asymmetry. Intriguingly and despite the symmetrical model setup, natural selection can nevertheless favour the spontaneous emergence of asymmetric evolutionary outcomes where, on average, one species exploits the other in a dynamical equilibrium.

Emergence of Cooperation in the thermodynamic limit

Triggers for cooperative behavior in the thermodynamic limit: a case study in Public goods game

Selection pressure/Noise driven cooperative behaviour in the thermodynamic limit of repeated games

Game susceptibility, Correlation and Payoff capacity as a measure of Cooperative behavior in the thermodynamic limit of some Social dilemmas

Emergence and resilience of cooperation in the spatial prisoner's dilemma via a reward mechanism

The collapse of cooperation in evolving games

Emergence of Cooperation in Spatial Public Goods Game with Conditional Participation

Nash equilibrium mapping vs Hamiltonian dynamics vs Darwinian evolution for some social dilemma games in the thermodynamic limit

Dynamics of heuristics selection for cooperative behaviour

An Explicit Construction of Self-dual 2-forms in Eight Dimensions

Spontaneous symmetry breaking of cooperation between species

Cooperation and its emergence in growing systems with cultural reproduction

Emergence of cooperation through chain-reaction death

The evolution of cooperation

Evolutionary dynamics of cooperation in neutral populations

Cooperation, Norms, and Revolutions: A Unified Game-Theoretical Approach

The emergence of cooperation in public goods games on randomly growing dynamic networks

Deterministic and stochastic cooperation transitions in evolutionary games on networks

Limitation of network inhomogeneity in improving cooperation in coevolutionary dynamics

Evolution of Cooperation on Stochastic Block Models

Emergence of Cooperation Induced by Preferential Learning