Abstract:Background mRNA translation involves simultaneous movement of multiple ribosomes on the mRNA and is also subject to regulatory mechanisms at different stages. Translation can be described by various codon-based models, including ODE, TASEP, and Petri net models. Although such models have been extensively used, the overlap and differences between these models and the implications of the assumptions of each model has not been systematically elucidated. The selection of the most appropriate modelling framework, and the most appropriate way to develop coarse-grained/fine-grained models in different contexts is not clear. Results We systematically analyze and compare how different modelling methodologies can be used to describe translation. We define various statistically equivalent codon-based simulation algorithms and analyze the importance of the update rule in determining the steady state, an aspect often neglected. Then a novel probabilistic Boolean network (PBN) model is proposed for modelling translation, which enjoys an exact numerical solution. This solution matches those of numerical simulation from other methods and acts as a complementary tool to analytical approximations and simulations. The advantages and limitations of various codon-based models are compared, and illustrated by examples with real biological complexities such as slow codons, premature termination and feedback regulation. Our studies reveal that while different models gives broadly similiar trends in many cases, important differences also arise and can be clearly seen, in the dependence of the translation rate on different parameters. Furthermore, the update rule affects the steady state solution. Conclusions The codon-based models are based on different levels of abstraction. Our analysis suggests that a multiple model approach to understanding translation allows one to ascertain which aspects of the conclusions are robust with respect to the choice of modelling methodology, and when (and why) important differences may arise. This approach also allows for an optimal use of analysis tools, which is especially important when additional complexities or regulatory mechanisms are included. This approach can provide a robust platform for dissecting translation, and results in an improved predictive framework for applications in systems and synthetic biology.

The key parameters that govern translation efficiency

Determinants of translation efficiency and accuracy

Deciphering mRNA Sequence Determinants of Protein Production Rate

aa-tRNA competition is crucial for the effective translation efficiency

A model for competition for ribosomes in the cell

On the Structure of the Initiation and Elongation Rates that Maximize Protein Production in the Ribosome Flow Model

Ribosome collisions and Translation efficiency: Optimization by codon usage and mRNA destabilization

mRNA translation from a unidirectional traffic perspective

Rate-Limiting Steps in Yeast Protein Translation

Mrna Translation and Protein Synthesis: an Analysis of Different Modelling Methodologies and a New PBN Based Approach

Translation with frameshifting of ribosome along mRNA transcript

Modelling the effect of ribosome mobility on the rate of protein synthesis

Translation elongation as a rate limiting step of protein production

Dynamics of ribosomes in mRNA translation under steady and non-steady state conditions

Translational Control by Ribosome Pausing in Bacteria: How a Non-uniform Pace of Translation Affects Protein Production and Folding

Dynamic basis of fidelity and speed in translation: Coordinated multistep mechanisms of elongation and termination

Trade-offs between tRNA abundance and mRNA secondary structure support smoothing of translation elongation rate

Maximizing protein translation rate in the non-homogeneous ribosome flow model: a convex optimization approach

Translation in the cell under fierce competition for shared resources: a mathematical model

Efficient Manipulations of Synonymous Mutations for Controlling Translation Rate: An Analytical Approach