Abstract:The response of thermodynamic systems perturbed out of an equilibrium
steady-state is described by the reciprocal and the fluctuation-dissipation
relations. The so-called fluctuation theorems extended the study of
fluctuations far beyond equilibrium. All these results rely on the crucial
assumption that the observer has complete information about the system. Such a
precise control is difficult to attain, hence the following questions are
compelling: Will an observer who has marginal information be able to perform an
effective thermodynamic analysis? Given that such observer will only establish
local equilibrium amidst the whirling of hidden degrees of freedom, by
perturbing the stalling currents will he/she observe equilibrium-like
fluctuations? We model the dynamics of open systems as Markov jump processes on
finite networks. We establish that: 1) While marginal currents do not obey a
full-fledged fluctuation relation, there exist effective affinities for which
an integral fluctuation relation holds; 2) Under reasonable assumptions on the
parametrization of the rates, effective and "real" affinities only differ by a
constant; 3) At stalling, i.e. where the marginal currents vanish, a
symmetrized fluctuation-dissipation relation holds while reciprocity does not;
4) There exists a notion of marginal time-reversal that plays a role akin to
that played by time-reversal for complete systems, which restores the
fluctuation relation and reciprocity. The above results hold for
configuration-space currents, and for phenomenological currents provided that
certain symmetries of the effective affinities are respected - a condition
whose range of validity we deem the most interesting question left open to
future inquiry. Our results are constructive and operational: we provide an
explicit expression for the effective affinities and propose a procedure to
measure them in laboratory.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to conduct effective thermodynamic analysis when the observer has incomplete information about the system. Specifically, the paper explores how to understand the statistical behavior of the system by studying partially observable currents (i.e., edge currents) when there are unobserved hidden degrees of freedom in the system. The paper raises the following two core questions:
1. **Can an observer with incomplete information conduct effective thermodynamic analysis?**
- The paper explores whether effective thermodynamic analysis can still be carried out when the observer can only obtain local equilibrium information and cannot fully understand all the details inside the system.
2. **Will edge currents exhibit fluctuations similar to the equilibrium state when the system is in a stagnant state?**
- Even when there are unobserved hidden currents inside the system, when the system is in a stagnant state (the edge current is zero), do the fluctuations of these edge currents still conform to the characteristics of the equilibrium state?
### Main Contributions
By establishing a broad theoretical framework, the paper solves the above - mentioned problems and draws the following main conclusions:
1. **Edge currents do not satisfy the complete fluctuation relation, but there are effective affinities, making the integrated fluctuation relation hold.**
- Even if edge currents do not satisfy the complete fluctuation relation, some effective affinities can be found, so that the integrated fluctuation relation still holds.
2. **Under reasonable parameter assumptions, the effective affinity differs from the "true" affinity by only a constant.**
- This means that under certain conditions, the effective affinity can approximate the true affinity.
3. **In the stagnant state, the symmetrized fluctuation - dissipation relation holds, but the reciprocity relation does not hold.**
- When the edge current is zero, the system exhibits a symmetrized fluctuation - dissipation relation, but the reciprocity relation is no longer applicable.
4. **There is a concept of edge - time reversal, similar to the time reversal in the complete system, which can restore the fluctuation relation and the reciprocity relation.**
- By introducing the concept of edge - time reversal, the fluctuation relation and the reciprocity relation can be restored to a certain extent.
5. **The effective affinity is part of the smallest model that an observer with only edge information can construct.**
- Based on its limited observation data, the observer can construct a minimum model to describe the steady - state behavior of the system.
6. **There are fluctuation relations in different levels of theories.**
- In different levels of theories, the fluctuation relation still holds, which provides a new perspective for understanding the statistical behavior of complex systems.
### Research Methods
The paper uses Markov jump processes to model the dynamics of open systems. The currents in the configuration space count the net number of transitions between configurations, and the conjugate forces quantify the thermodynamic cost of these transitions. Through this framework, the paper explores in detail the statistical behavior of edge currents and their thermodynamic properties.
### Conclusions
The paper provides a theoretical framework for dealing with thermodynamic systems with incomplete information. This framework is not only theoretically significant but also provides operational suggestions for experimental verification, such as determining effective affinities through simple tuning procedures. These results provide new tools and methods for understanding and analyzing the thermodynamic behavior of complex systems.