Abstract:Some low-mass stars appear to have larger radii than predicted by standard 1D structure models; prior work has suggested that inefficient convective heat transport, due to rotation and/or magnetism, may ultimately be responsible. We examine this issue using 1D stellar models constructed using Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA). First, we consider standard models that do not explicitly include rotational/magnetic effects, with convective inhibition modeled by decreasing a depth-independent mixing length theory (MLT) parameter $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$ (following Cox et al. 1981; Chabrier et al. 2007). We provide formulae linking changes in $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$ to changes in the interior specific entropy, and hence to the stellar radius. Next, we modify the MLT formulation in MESA to mimic explicitly the influence of rotation and magnetism, using formulations suggested by Stevenson (1979) and MacDonald & Mullan (2014) respectively. We find rapid rotation in these models has a negligible impact on stellar structure, primarily because a star's adiabat, and hence its radius, is predominantly affected by layers near the surface; convection is rapid and largely uninfluenced by rotation there. Magnetic fields, if they influenced convective transport in the manner described by MacDonald & Mullan (2014), could lead to more noticeable radius inflation. Finally, we show that these non-standard effects on stellar structure can be fabricated using a depth-dependent $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$: a non-magnetic, non-rotating model can be produced that is virtually indistinguishable from one that explicitly parameterizes rotation and/or magnetism using the two formulations above. We provide formulae linking the radially-variable $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$ to these putative MLT reformulations.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is that the radii of low-mass stars are 5-15% larger than predicted by standard 1-dimensional structure models. This phenomenon may lead to incorrect estimates of the ages of pre-main-sequence stars. The authors suggest that this structural change may be due to some mechanisms inhibiting convection, particularly the effects of rotation and magnetic fields. Specifically, the paper investigates these effects using 1-dimensional stellar models (employing the Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics, MESA code) to explore how rotation and magnetic fields affect the radii and entropy of fully convective stars. ### Main Issues Summary: 1. **Low-mass star radius inflation**: Some low-mass stars have radii that are 5-15% larger than predicted by standard 1-dimensional structure models. 2. **Cause investigation**: This radius inflation may be due to the inhibition of convection by rotation and/or magnetic fields. 3. **Model validation**: By modifying the mixing length theory (MLT) to simulate the effects of rotation and magnetic fields, the paper validates whether these non-standard effects can explain the observed radius inflation. ### Research Methods: - **Standard model**: First, consider the standard model that does not explicitly include the effects of rotation and magnetic fields, simulating convection inhibition by adjusting the mixing length parameter $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$. - **Rotation and magnetic field models**: Then modify the MLT formula, explicitly simulating the effects of rotation and magnetic fields using the methods proposed by Stevenson (1979) and MacDonald & Mullan (2014). - **Depth-dependent $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$**: Finally, demonstrate how to replicate these non-standard effects in the standard model by introducing a depth-dependent $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$, thereby simulating the effects of rotation and magnetic fields. ### Key Findings: - **Rotation effects**: The impact of rapid rotation on stellar structure is minimal, mainly because the adiabatic gradient and radius of the star are primarily influenced by the layers near the surface, where the convection speed is fast and not significantly affected by rotation. - **Magnetic field effects**: If the magnetic field affects convective transport as described by MacDonald & Mullan (2014), it may lead to more significant radius inflation. - **Depth-dependent $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$**: By introducing a depth-dependent $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$, the standard model can accurately replicate the effects of rotation and magnetic fields on stellar superadiabaticity and radius. ### Conclusion: Through detailed numerical simulations and theoretical analysis, this paper explores the effects of rotation and magnetic fields on the radii and entropy of low-mass fully convective stars and proposes a method to simulate these non-standard effects using a depth-dependent $\alpha_{\text{MLT}}$. This provides new perspectives and tools for understanding the radius inflation phenomenon of low-mass stars.

The Radius and Entropy of a Magnetized, Rotating Fully-convective Star: Analysis With Depth-dependent Mixing Length Theories

The Stagger-grid: A grid of 3D stellar atmosphere models - III. The relation to mixing-length convection theory

Magnetic Inhibition of Convection and the Fundamental Properties of Low-Mass Stars. I. Stars with a Radiative Core

THE ROLE OF THE MAGNETOROTATIONAL INSTABILITY IN MASSIVE STARS

On the Possibility of an Upper Limit on Magnetically Induced Radius Inflation in Low-mass Stars

Angular momentum and chemical transport by azimuthal magnetorotational instability in radiative stellar interiors

The effective magnetic Prandtl number in magnetized and differentially rotating stellar radiation zones

A Review of the Mixing Length Theory of Convection in 1D Stellar Modeling

Turbulence Supported Massive Star Envelopes

Impact of different approaches to computing rotating stellar models. I. The case of solar metallicity

Convection with Misaligned Gravity and Rotation: Simulations and Rotating Mixing Length Theory

On Convective Turnover Times and Dynamos In Low-Mass Stars

Rotation in stellar interiors: General formulation and an asteroseismic-calibrated transport by the Tayler instability

Impact of different approaches for computing rotating stellar models I. The solar metallicity case

Coriolis darkening in late-type stars. II. Effect of self-sustained magnetic fields in stratified convective envelopes

Magneto-convective models of red dwarfs: constraints imposed by the lithium abundance

Diffusion-plus-drift models for the mass leakage from centrifugal magnetospheres of magnetic hot-stars

A Magnetic Confinement vs. Rotation Classification of Massive-Star Magnetospheres

Subcritical Saturation of the Magnetorotational Instability Through Mean Magnetic Field Generation

Effect of Differential Rotation on Magnetic Braking of Low-Mass and Solar-Like Stars: A Proof-of-Concept Study

Modeling of Magneto-Rotational Stellar Evolution I. Method and first applications