Disks Around Merging Binary Black Holes: From GW150914 to Supermassive Black Holes

Abid Khan,Vasileios Paschalidis,Milton Ruiz,Stuart L. Shapiro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.97.044036

2018-02-25

Abstract:We perform magnetohydrodynamic simulations in full general relativity of disk accretion onto nonspinning black hole binaries with mass ratio 36:29. We survey different disk models which differ in their scale height, total size and magnetic field to quantify the robustness of previous simulations on the initial disk model. Scaling our simulations to LIGO GW150914 we find that such systems could explain possible gravitational wave and electromagnetic counterparts such as the Fermi GBM hard X-ray signal reported 0.4s after GW150915 ended. Scaling our simulations to supermassive binary black holes, we find that observable flow properties such as accretion rate periodicities, the emergence of jets throughout inspiral, merger and post-merger, disk temperatures, thermal frequencies, and the time-delay between merger and the boost in jet outflows that we reported in earlier studies display only modest dependence on the initial disk model we consider here.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Astrophysics of Galaxies,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about how the accretion disks in and around the binary black hole systems (BHBHs) generate electromagnetic (EM) signals during the merger process. Specifically, through magnetohydrodynamic simulations under full general relativity, the researchers explored the influence of accretion disk models under different initial conditions on the following phenomena:

1. **Jet formation**: The researchers focused on how accretion disks of different thicknesses affect the formation and development of jets.
2. **Periodic accretion rate**: They explored whether the periodic changes in the accretion rate are related to specific physical parameters (such as the mass ratio of the binary black holes).
3. **Post - merger jet enhancement**: They studied whether the enhancement of the jet power after the merger and its time delay depend on the initial accretion disk model.

### Research background
- **Gravitational wave detection**: On September 14, 2015, the LIGO and Virgo collaborations directly detected the gravitational wave signal GW150914 for the first time, and this event was confirmed as the merger process of two non - rotating black holes.
- **Electromagnetic counterpart signal**: The Gamma - ray Burst Monitor (GBM) of the Fermi satellite reported a hard X - ray signal (GW150914 - GBM) 0.4 seconds after the GW150914 event, which triggered a discussion on whether the binary black hole merger can generate electromagnetic signals.

### Research methods
- **Numerical simulation**: The researchers used the Illinois GRMHD AMR code for simulation. This code is based on the Cactus/Carpet infrastructure and solves the Baumgarte - Shapiro - Shibata - Nakamura (BSSN) equations and the ideal GRMHD equations.
- **Initial conditions**: They simulated accretion disks of different thicknesses with a mass ratio of \(q=\frac{29}{36}\) and an initial orbital separation of approximately 14M.

### Main findings
1. **Accretion disk structure and evolution**:
- The simulation results show that a high - density spiral accretion flow is formed during the entire inspiral and merger process.
- After the merger, a preliminary jet is formed around the single newly - born black hole.

2. **Accretion rate periodicity**:
- The accretion rate reaches a quasi - steady state at approximately \(t/M\sim1500\), showing periodic changes with a period of about 0.8 times the average orbital period.
- This periodic feature is consistent in different accretion disk models, indicating that it is less sensitive to the initial model.

3. **Jet enhancement**:
- After the merger, the Poynting radiation power of the jet is significantly enhanced, and there is a certain time delay.
- The efficiency of jet enhancement increases as the thickness of the accretion disk decreases.

### Conclusions
- Through numerical simulations, this study verified that the accretion disks in and around the binary black hole merger process can generate electromagnetic signals, explaining the possibility of the GW150914 - GBM signal.
- The accretion disk models under different initial conditions have little influence on the formation of jets, the periodic changes in the accretion rate, and the time delay of jet enhancement after the merger, indicating that these phenomena are relatively robust.

### Formula display
- **Accretion rate**:
\[
\dot{M}=-\int_{\text{AH}}T^{t}_{\mu}\xi^{\mu}dA
\]
where \(T^{t}_{\mu}\) is the energy - momentum tensor, \(\xi^{\mu}\) is the Killing vector, and \(\text{AH}\) represents the black hole horizon.

- **Poynting radiation power**:
\[
L_{\text{EM}}=\oint_{S}T^{\nu}_{\mu,(\text{EM})}\xi_{\nu}dS
\]
where \(T^{\nu}_{\mu,(\text{EM})}\) is the electromagnetic stress - energy tensor and \(S\) is the coordinate sphere.

Through these simulation results, the researchers provided important theoretical support for understanding multi - messenger astronomy in the binary black hole merger process.