Tracking dynamo mechanisms from local energy transfers: Application to the von Kármán sodium dynamo

M. Creff,H. Faller,B. Dubrulle,J.-L. Guermond,C. Nore

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0174251

IF: 2.2

2024-02-01

Physics of Plasmas

Abstract:Motivated by the observation that dynamo is a conversion mechanism between kinetic and magnetic energy, we develop a new approach to unravel dynamo mechanism based on local (in space, scale, and time) energy budget describing dissipation and scale-by-scale energy transfers. Our approach is based upon a new filtering approach that can be used effectively for any type of meshes, including unstructured ones. The corresponding formalism is very general and applies to any geometry or boundary conditions. We further discuss the interpretation of these energy transfers in the context of fast dynamo and anomalous dissipation. We apply it to the results from direct numerical simulations of the von Kármán Sodium setup (referred to as VKS) using a finite element code, showing dynamo action for two types of impellers (steel or soft iron) in the magnetic field growth and saturation phases. Although the two types of dynamo hardly differ from the mean-field theory point of view (the velocity fields are the same in both cases), the locality of our formalism allows us to trace the origin of the differences between these two types of dynamo: for steel impellers, the dynamo is due to the transfer of velocity energy both in the bulk and in the vicinity of the impellers, whereas for soft iron impellers, the dynamo effect mainly comes from the rotation of the blades. We finally discuss possible signatures of precursors to anomalous dissipation and fast dynamo, which could become relevant in the inviscid limit.

physics, fluids & plasmas

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to track the dynamo mechanism through local energy transfer, especially in the application in the Von Kármán Sodium dynamo (VKS).

### Specific problem description:
1. **Conversion of the dynamo mechanism**:
A dynamo is a mechanism that converts kinetic energy into magnetic energy. The paper aims to develop a new method, based on the local (space, scale and time) energy budget, to describe the processes of dissipation and step - by - step energy transfer, in order to reveal the essence of the dynamo mechanism.

2. **Analysis of energy transfer**:
The paper proposes a new filtering method, which can be effectively applied to any type of grid (including unstructured grids). This method is very general and is applicable to any geometric shape or boundary condition. The goal is to obtain the location information of the dynamo effect by analyzing the exchange locations (in scale, space and time) between kinetic energy and magnetic energy.

3. **Differences between two types of dynamos**:
The paper studies the behaviors of two types of dynamos (using steel stirrers and soft - iron stirrers) in the magnetic field growth and saturation stages. Although from the perspective of the mean - field theory, these two dynamos are almost indistinguishable (the velocity fields are the same), through local formalism, the source of the differences between these two dynamos can be traced.

4. **Precursors of fast dynamos and anomalous dissipation**:
The paper also discusses the possible precursors of fast dynamos and anomalous dissipation, and these phenomena may become relevant in the inviscid limit.

---

### Summary of mathematical formulas:
The following are some of the key formulas involved in the paper:

1. **MHD equations**:
- Momentum equation:
$$
\frac{\partial u}{\partial t}+(u\cdot\nabla)u - \nu\nabla^{2}u+\nabla p = -\frac{1}{\rho}(\nabla\times b)\times b + f
$$
- Magnetic induction equation:
$$
\frac{\partial b}{\partial t}=\nabla\times(u\times b)-\eta\nabla^{2}b
$$

2. **Local energy budget**:
- Filtered kinetic energy equation:
$$
\frac{\partial E_{c}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot J_{NS}+D_{\nu}+D_{u}=-T_{u!b}+P
$$
- Filtered magnetic energy equation:
$$
\frac{\partial E_{m}}{\partial t}+\nabla\cdot J_{M}+D_{r}+D_{b}+D_{lr}+D_{lT}=T_{u!b}+M_{l}
$$

3. **Dynamo growth rate**:
- The local dynamo growth rate is defined as:
$$
k_{m}=\frac{T_{u!b}+M_{l}-D_{r}-D_{b}-D_{lr}-D_{lT}}{\langle E_{m}\rangle}
$$

4. **Filter definition**:
- Given a vector field $u$ and a scale $\ell$, the filtered field $g = u_{\ell}$ is defined as:
$$
g-\ell^{2}\nabla^{2}g = u
$$

---

### Conclusion:
Through the method of local energy budget, the paper successfully reveals the conversion mechanism between kinetic energy and magnetic energy in the Von Kármán Sodium dynamo, and explains the influence of different material stirrers on the dynamo behavior. This method provides a new perspective for understanding complex turbulent dynamos and lays the foundation for further research on fast dynamos and anomalous dissipation.