Abstract:Methane is a greenhouse gas with a significant warming effect on climate — only water vapour and carbon dioxide are more important — yet the factors influencing its atmospheric concentration are poorly understood. In particular, a rapid rise in methane levels in the mid-twentieth century gradually (but temporarily) levelled off around the turn of the millennium; the reasons for this decline in growth rate are still being debated. Two new studies shed light on this conundrum — but reach conflicting conclusions. Fuu Ming Kai et al. measure differences in the concentration and isotopic signature of methane between the Northern and Southern Hemispheres and conclude that reduced microbial activity in wetlands was primarily responsible. Changing rice agricultural practices seem to explain about half of the Northern Hemispheric trend. By contrast, Murat Aydin et al. combine measurements of ethane trapped in Antarctic ice with a simple atmospheric model and conclude that the slow-down was caused by reduced methane emissions from fossil-fuel production. In News and Views, Martin Heimann discusses the differing findings of these two studies. Methane and ethane are the most abundant hydrocarbons in the atmosphere and they affect both atmospheric chemistry and climate. Both gases are emitted from fossil fuels and biomass burning, whereas methane (CH4) alone has large sources from wetlands, agriculture, landfills and waste water. Here we use measurements in firn (perennial snowpack) air from Greenland and Antarctica to reconstruct the atmospheric variability of ethane (C2H6) during the twentieth century. Ethane levels rose from early in the century until the 1980s, when the trend reversed, with a period of decline over the next 20 years. We find that this variability was primarily driven by changes in ethane emissions from fossil fuels; these emissions peaked in the 1960s and 1970s at 14–16 teragrams per year (1 Tg = 1012 g) and dropped to 8–10 Tg yr−1 by the turn of the century. The reduction in fossil-fuel sources is probably related to changes in light hydrocarbon emissions associated with petroleum production and use. The ethane-based fossil-fuel emission history is strikingly different from bottom-up estimates of methane emissions from fossil-fuel use1,2, and implies that the fossil-fuel source of methane started to decline in the 1980s and probably caused the late twentieth century slow-down in the growth rate of atmospheric methane3,4.

The isotopic composition of methane in polar ice cores

Shifts in Identity and Activity of Methanotrophs in Arctic Lake Sediments in Response to Temperature Changes

A gas chromatography/pyrolysis/isotope ratio mass spectrometry system for high-precision deltaD measurements of atmospheric methane extracted from ice cores

Large Fractionations of C and H Isotopes Related to Methane Oxidation in Arctic Lakes

Atmospheric Methane over the Past 2000 Years from A Sub-Tropical Ice Core, Central Himalayas

Microbial origin of excess greenhouse gases in glacial ice

Greenhouse gases in the Earth system: a palaeoclimate perspective

Atmospheric composition 1 million years ago from blue ice in the Allan Hills, Antarctica

Methane flux from Beringian coastal wetlands for the past 20,000 years

Recent Decreases in Fossil-Fuel Emissions of Ethane and Methane Derived from Firn Air

A New Himalayan Ice Core CH4 Record: Possible Hints at the Preindustrial Latitudinal Gradient

Preindustrial 14CH4 indicates greater anthropogenic fossil CH4 emissions

Atmospheric constraints on changing Arctic CH4 emissions

Two-million-year-old snapshots of atmospheric gases from Antarctic ice

Temperature and Methane Changes over the Past 1000 Years Recorded in Dasuopu Glacier (central Himalaya) Ice Core

Discrimination of Abiogenic and Biogenic Alkane Gases

Potential Methane Production Rates and Its Carbon Isotopic Composition from Ornithogenic Tundra Soils in Coastal Antarctica

3D climate simulations of the Archean find that methane has a strong cooling effect at high concentrations

Temporal and Spatial Variations of a Tmospheric Methane Concentration and Δ 13 C-CH 4 Near the Surface on the Millor Peninsula, East Antarctica

Δ13c-Ch4 Reveals CH4 Variations over Oceans from Mid-Latitudes to the Arctic

The older ice, the better science