Exercise Motivation and Self-Efficacy Vary Among Patients with Heart Failure – An Explorative Analysis Using Data from the HF-Wii Study
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S314414
2021-10-20
Patient Preference and Adherence
Abstract:Leonie Klompstra, 1 Tiny Jaarsma, 1 Anna Strömberg, 1, 2 Lorraine S Evangelista, 3 Martje HL van der Wal 1, 4 On behalf of the HF-Wii Study Team 1 Department of Health, Medicine and Caring Sciences, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden; 2 Department of Cardiology, Linköping University, Linköping, Sweden; 3 University of Texas Medical Branch School of Nursing, Galveston, TX, USA; 4 Department of Cardiology, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands Correspondence: Leonie Klompstra Linköping University, Department of Health, Medicine and Caring Sciences, Linköping, SE 601 74, Sweden Tel +4611363629 Fax +4611125448 Email Purpose: To examine profiles in patients with heart failure (HF) regarding their exercise motivation and self-efficacy. Patients & Methods: The baseline data of patients with HF participating in the HF-Wii study were analysed. In total, 517 patients were divided into four groups based on their exercise motivation (exercise motivation index) and self-efficacy (exercise self-efficacy scale). To describe the differences in demographic and clinical variables between the groups, chi-square cross-tabulations and ANOVAs were conducted. Results: The four groups were labelled as insecure avoiders (25%), laid-back strugglers (10%), conscientious self-doubters (42%) and determined achievers (22%). Patients' profiles differ according to their motivations and self-efficacy towards exercise. Most patients were conscientious self-doubters (high motivation and low self-efficacy), and these patients had more comorbidities and lower exercise capacity compared to the other groups, which could decrease their confidence in exercising. However, only half of the patients who were determined achievers (high motivation and high self-efficacy) reached the recommended amount of physical activity per week. This indicates that motivation and self-efficacy are crucial determinants, but more factors are important for becoming more physically active. Conclusion: Understanding patients' motivations and self-efficacy are necessary in order to provide meaningful physical activity counselling and promotion. Keywords: motivation, self-efficacy, physical activity, exercise, heart failure This study examined profiles in patients with heart failure regarding their motivation and confidence towards exercise. In total, 517 patients were divided into four groups based on their exercise motivation and confidence to exercise. The four groups were labelled as insecure avoiders (25%), laid-back strugglers (10%), conscientious self-doubters (42%) and determined achievers (22%). Patients' profiles differ according to their motivations and confidence towards exercise. Most patients were conscientious self-doubters (high motivation and low confidence), and these patients suffered from more diseases and lower exercise capacity compared to the other groups, which could decrease their confidence in exercising. However, only half of the patients who were determined achievers (high motivation and high confidence) reached the recommended amount of physical activity per week (150 min exercise a week). This indicates that motivation and confidence are crucial determinants, but more factors are important for becoming more physically active. The health benefits of regular exercise in patients with heart failure (HF) are widely recognized, and exercise training is now a well-established therapy for patients with HF. 1,2 Regular exercise is safe, can decrease mortality, 3,4 and can improve exercise capacity and quality of life. 5,6 Despite the benefits and strong recommendations in the ESC guidelines, 7 adherence to exercise recommendations is low (39%), and is lower than most other self-management activities such as adherence to diet (83%) or medication (higher than 90%). 8,9 There is growing evidence that crucial determinants of exercise adherence are self-efficacy and motivation. Self-efficacy refers to the belief in one's ability to execute tasks in a given situation. 10,11 Self-efficacy is related to overcoming barriers to exercise, and has been specifically linked to exercise adherence and maintenance in patients with HF. 12–15 Barriers to exercise can be patient-related (eg, inadequate social support), social and economic factors, barriers in the health care team system (eg, only 10% of eligible HF patients receive a cardiac rehabilitation referral), condition-related factors (eg, experience of symptoms) or therapy-related factors (eg, enjoyment of exercise). 16–19 A lack of motivation can also be a barrier, -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal