An Application of Mosaic Diagrams to the Visualization of Set Relationships

Saturnino Luz,Masood Masoodian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1711.03065

2017-11-09

Abstract:We present an application of mosaic diagrams to the visualisation of set relations. Venn and Euler diagrams are the best known visual representations of sets and their relationships (intersections, containment or subsets, exclusion or disjointness). In recent years, alternative forms of visualisation have been proposed. Among them, linear diagrams have been shown to compare favourably to Venn and Euler diagrams, in supporting non-interactive assessment of set relationships. Recent studies that compared several variants of linear diagrams have demonstrated that users perform best at tasks involving identification of intersections, disjointness and subsets when using a horizontally drawn linear diagram with thin lines representing sets, and employing vertical lines as guide lines. The essential visual task the user needs to perform in order to interpret this kind of diagram is vertical alignment of parallel lines and detection of overlaps. Space-filling mosaic diagrams which support this same visual task have been used in other applications, such as the visualization of schedules of activities, where they have been shown to be superior to linear Gantt charts. In this paper, we present an application of mosaic diagrams for visualization of set relationships, and compare it to linear diagrams in terms of accuracy, time-to-answer, and subjective ratings of perceived task difficulty. The study participants exhibited similar performance on both visualisations, suggesting that mosaic diagrams are a good alternative to Venn and Euler diagrams, and that the choice between linear diagrams and mosaics may be solely guided by visual design considerations.

Graphics,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the effectiveness and applicability of mosaic diagrams in visualizing set relations and compare them with linear diagrams. Specifically, the research aims to explore the following issues:

1. **Whether mosaic diagrams can be an effective alternative to Venn diagrams and Euler diagrams**: Venn diagrams and Euler diagrams are currently the most commonly used methods for visualizing set relations, but they have limitations when dealing with multiple sets. Therefore, researchers hope to find a new visualization method that can better represent the relations between sets.

2. **Differences in performance between mosaic diagrams and linear diagrams in terms of task completion time, accuracy, and subjective difficulty rating**: Through experimental comparison, researchers hope to understand the performance of these two types of charts when users perform specific tasks, so as to provide a basis for choosing appropriate visualization tools.

3. **The visual design advantages of mosaic diagrams**: Researchers hope to prove through experiments whether the space - filling property of mosaic diagrams helps to improve users' task completion efficiency, especially when it comes to tasks such as vertical alignment.

### Research Background

- **The importance of set visualization**: The study of sets and their relations is of fundamental significance in fields such as mathematics, logic, and computer science. Although traditional Venn diagrams and Euler diagrams are widely used, they have scalability and usability problems when dealing with multiple sets.

- **The advantages of linear diagrams**: In recent years, linear diagrams have been proposed as an alternative method and have shown better performance than Venn diagrams and Euler diagrams in some tasks. Linear diagrams represent set relations through horizontal lines and vertical guide lines, and users can identify intersections, subsets, and disjoint relations through vertical alignment.

- **The application of mosaic diagrams**: Mosaic diagrams were initially used for visualizing time - series data, such as the timelines of multimedia conference records. It represents the time relations of events by filling space and has been proven to be superior to traditional Gantt charts in some tasks. Therefore, researchers speculate that mosaic diagrams may also be suitable for visualizing set relations.

### Experimental Design

To evaluate the effectiveness of mosaic diagrams and linear diagrams, researchers designed a series of experimental tasks, including:

- **Task types**: Identifying intersections, subsets, and disjointness.
- **Difficulty levels**: Easy tasks and hard tasks, which respectively involve the relations of single sets and multiple sets.
- **Chart types**: Linear diagrams and mosaic diagrams.

Through these tasks, researchers collected participants' task completion time, accuracy, and subjective difficulty rating to comprehensively evaluate the performance of the two charts.

### Conclusion

The research shows that participants perform similarly when using mosaic diagrams and linear diagrams, indicating that mosaic diagrams can be an effective alternative to Venn diagrams and Euler diagrams. In addition, the study also found that the choice of which chart may depend more on visual design considerations rather than significant differences in task performance.

In conclusion, this paper provides new insights into the visualization of set relations through empirical research and provides valuable references for future research and applications.