Asymmetric Nonlinear System is Not sufficient for Non-Reciprocal Quantum Wave Diode

Gaomin Wu,Yang Long,Jie Ren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.97.205423

2017-11-07

Abstract:We demonstrate symmetric wave propagations in asymmetric nonlinear quantum systems. By solving the nonlinear Schördinger equation, we first analytically prove the existence of symmetric transmission in asymmetric systems with a single nonlinear delta-function interface. We then point out that a finite width of the nonlinear interface region is necessary to produce non-reciprocity in asymmetric systems. However, a geometrical resonant condition for breaking non-reciprocal propagation is then identified theoretically and verified numerically. With such a resonant condition, the nonlinear interface region of finite width behaves like a single nonlinear delta-barrier so that wave propagations in the forward and backward directions are identical under arbitrary incident wave intensity. As such, reciprocity re-emerges periodically in the asymmetric nonlinear system when changing the width of interface region. Finally, similar resonant conditions of discrete nonlinear Schördinger equation are discussed. Therefore, we have identified instances of Reciprocity Theorem that breaking spatial symmetry in nonlinear interface systems is not sufficient to produce non-reciprocal wave propagation.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Optics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to verify and correct the existing explanations regarding non - reciprocal wave propagation in nonlinear quantum systems. Specifically, the paper explores the traditional view of whether spatial asymmetry and nonlinearity are sufficient to generate non - reciprocal wave propagation in nonlinear quantum systems, and points out that this explanation has flaws.

### Main problems:
1. **Verification and correction of existing explanations**:
- The paper re - examines the traditional explanation that "spatial asymmetry and nonlinearity are sufficient to generate non - reciprocal wave propagation" and proves that this explanation is incorrect.

2. **Influence of geometric properties**:
- The influence of geometric properties (such as the width of the nonlinear interface region) on non - reciprocal wave propagation is introduced, and the phenomenon of the reappearance of reciprocity under certain resonance conditions is discussed.

3. **Sufficient conditions for non - reciprocal wave propagation**:
- By studying one - dimensional nonlinear quantum structures, the paper determines three sufficient conditions required for non - reciprocal wave propagation: nonlinearity, spatial asymmetry, and an interface scattering region of finite width.

### Specific problems and solutions:
- **Single nonlinear δ - function potential**:
- Research shows that when nonlinearity occurs only at one point, forward wave propagation is the same as backward wave propagation, so spatial asymmetry alone is not sufficient to generate non - reciprocity.

- **Two nonlinear δ - function potentials**:
- By introducing two nonlinear δ - function potentials, the paper shows that non - reciprocity can be achieved in this case. However, as the interface width changes, when specific resonance conditions are met, reciprocity will reappear.

- **Discrete nonlinear Schrödinger equation model**:
- The discrete nonlinear Schrödinger equation (DNLS) is used to further verify the results of the above - mentioned continuous model, and similar resonance conditions are found.

### Conclusion:
The main conclusion drawn by the paper is that in nonlinear quantum systems, spatial asymmetry and nonlinearity alone are not sufficient to ensure non - reciprocal wave propagation. Geometric properties, especially the width of the nonlinear interface region, also need to be considered. When the interface width meets specific resonance conditions, reciprocity will reappear. Therefore, geometric properties are one of the key factors affecting non - reciprocal wave propagation.

Through these studies, the paper provides a new perspective for future experimental and theoretical work, especially in designing multi - layer nonlinear phonon or photonic crystals with selective frequency reciprocity.