Knowledge gaps in the early growth of semantic networks

Ann E. Sizemore,Elisabeth A. Karuza,Chad Giusti,Danielle S. Bassett

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1709.00133

2017-09-01

Abstract:Understanding the features of and mechanisms behind language learning can provide insights into the general process of knowledge acquisition. Recent methods from network science applied to language learning have advanced the field, particularly by noting associations between densely connected words and acquisition. However, the importance of sparse areas of the network, or knowledge gaps, remains unexplored. Here we create a semantic feature network in which words correspond to nodes and in which connections correspond to semantic similarity. We develop a new analytical approach built on principles of applied topology to query the prevalence of knowledge gaps, which we propose manifest as cavities within the network. We detect topological cavities of multiple dimensions in the growing semantic feature network of children ages 16 to 30 months. The pattern of cavity appearance matches that of a constrained null model, created by predefining the affinity of each node for connections. Furthermore, when word acquisition time is computed from children of mothers with differing levels of education, we find that despite variation at the word level, the global organization as measured by persistent homology remains comparable. We show that topological properties of a node correlate with filling in cavities better than simple lexical properties such as the length and frequency of the corresponding word. Finally, we show that the large-scale architecture of the semantic feature network is topologically accommodating to many node orders. We discuss the importance of topology in language learning, and we speculate that the formation and filling of knowledge gaps may be a robust feature of knowledge acquisition.

Neurons and Cognition