Abstract:We report an inconsistency found in probability theory (also referred to as measure-theoretic probability). For probability measures induced by real-valued random variables, we deduce an equality such that one side of the equality is a probability, but the other side is not. For probability measures induced by extended random variables, we deduce an equality such that its two sides are unequal probabilities. The deduced expressions are erroneous only when it can be proved that measure-theoretic probability is a theory free from contradiction. However, such a proof does not exist. The inconsistency appears only in the theory rather than in the physical world, and will not affect practical applications as long as ideal events in the theory (which will not occur physically) are not mistaken for observable events in the real world. Nevertheless, unlike known paradoxes in mathematics, the inconsistency cannot be explained away and hence must be resolved. The assumption of infinite additivity in the theory is relevant to the inconsistency, and may cause confusion of ideal events and real events. As illustrated by an example in this article, since abstract properties of mathematical entities in theoretical thinking are not necessarily properties of physical quantities observed in the real world, mistaking the former for the latter may lead to misinterpreting random phenomena observed in experiments with microscopic systems. Actually the inconsistency is due to the notion of numbers adopted in conventional mathematics. A possible way to resolve the inconsistency is to treat numbers from the viewpoint of constructive mathematics.

Asymptotic equivalence of probability measures and stochastic processes

Asymptotic Equivalence of Quantum Stochastic Models

Ensemble equivalence and asymptotic equipartition property in information theory

Quantum Macrostates, Equivalence of Ensembles and an H-Theorem

Representations and Divergences in the Space of Probability Measures and Stochastic Thermodynamics

Asymptotic Stochastic Comparison of Random Processes

Gaussian concentration bound and Ensemble equivalence in generic quantum many-body systems including long-range interaction

Asymptotic Behavior of a Sequence of Conditional Probability Distributions and the Canonical Ensemble

Asymptotic equivalence of discretely observed diffusion processes and their Euler scheme: small variance case

On the equivalence between stochastic baker's maps and two-dimensional spin systems

On the equivalence between Fourier-based and Wasserstein distances for probability measures on $\mathbb N$

Equivalence of two orthogonalities between probability measures

ASYMPTOTIC EQUIVALENCE OF RISK MEASURES UNDER DEPENDENCE UNCERTAINTY

On the Equivalence of Statistical Distances for Isotropic Convex Measures

Limits of Probability Measures With General Coefficients

On a class of stochastic partial differential equations with multiple invariant measures

Stability and Invariant Measure Asymptotics in a Model for Heavy Particles in Rough Turbulent Flows

Inconsistency of Measure-Theoretic Probability and Random Behavior of Microscopic Systems

Asymptotic Equivalence for Nonparametric Generalized Linear Models

Limit theorems of invariant measures for multivalued McKean-Vlasov stochastic differential equations

The Vlasov continuum limit for the classical microcanonical ensemble