Time-optimal control strategies in SIR epidemic models

Luca Bolzoni,Elena Bonacini,Cinzia Soresina,Maria Groppi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1706.04447

2017-06-14

Abstract:We investigate the time-optimal control problem in SIR (Susceptible-Infected-Recovered) epidemic models, focusing on different control policies: vaccination, isolation, culling, and reduction of transmission. Applying the Pontryagin's Minimum Principle (PMP) to the unconstrained control problems (i.e. without costs of control or resource limitations), we prove that, for all the policies investigated, only bang-bang controls with at most one switch are admitted. When a switch occurs, the optimal strategy is to delay the control action some amount of time and then apply the control at the maximum rate for the remainder of the outbreak. This result is in contrast with previous findings on the unconstrained problems of minimizing the total infectious burden over an outbreak, where the optimal strategy is to use the maximal control for the entire epidemic. Then, the critical consequence of our results is that, in a wide range of epidemiological circumstances, it may be impossible to minimize the total infectious burden while minimizing the epidemic duration, and vice versa. Moreover, numerical simulations highlighted additional unexpected results, showing that the optimal control can be delayed also when the control reproduction number is lower than one and that the switching time from no control to maximum control can even occur after the peak of infection has been reached. Our results are especially important for livestock diseases where the minimization of outbreaks duration is a priority due to sanitary restrictions imposed to farms during ongoing epidemics, such as animal movements and export bans.

Optimization and Control

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to find the time - optimal control strategy to minimize the duration of the epidemic in the SIR (Susceptible - Infected - Recovered) epidemic model. Specifically, the paper explores different control policies, including vaccination, isolation, culling, and reducing transmission, to determine the optimal implementation of these policies under different conditions. By applying Pontryagin's Minimum Principle (PMP) to the unconstrained control problem, the author proves that for all the policies studied, only "bang - bang" controls with at most one switch are allowed. This means that when a switch occurs, the optimal strategy is to delay the control action for a period of time and then implement the control at the maximum rate for the remaining time of the epidemic.

This finding is in contrast to the previous research results on the unconstrained problem of minimizing the total infection burden throughout the epidemic, which indicates that the optimal strategy is to always use maximum control throughout the epidemic. Therefore, the key conclusion of the paper is that it may be impossible to simultaneously minimize the total infection burden and the duration of the epidemic in a wide range of epidemiological situations.

In addition, numerical simulations reveal some additional unexpected results, showing that even when the basic reproduction number under control is below 1, the optimal control can be delayed, and the switching time from no control to maximum control may even occur after the peak of infection. These results are particularly important for livestock diseases, because in this case, minimizing the duration of the epidemic is a priority due to the hygiene restrictions imposed on farms during the epidemic outbreak (such as animal movement and export bans).