Abstract:In 1950, Nash proposed a natural equilibrium solution concept for games hence called Nash equilibrium, and proved that all finite games have at least one. The proof is through a simple yet ingenious application of Brouwer’s (or, in another version Kakutani’s) fixed point theorem, the most sophisticated result in his era’s topology—in fact, recent algorithmic work has established that Nash equilibria are computationally equivalent to fixed points. In this paper, we propose a new class of universal non-equilibrium solution concepts arising from an important theorem in the topology of dynamical systems that was unavailable to Nash. This approach starts with both a game and a learning dynamics, defined over mixed strategies. The Nash equilibria are fixpoints of the dynamics, but the system behavior is captured by an object far more general than the Nash equilibrium that is known in dynamical systems theory as chain recurrent set. Informally, once we focus on this solution concept—this notion of “the outcome of the game”—every game behaves like a potential game with the dynamics converging to these states. In other words, unlike Nash equilibria, this solution concept is algorithmic in the sense that it has a constructive proof of existence. We characterize this solution for simple benchmark games under replicator dynamics, arguably the best known evolutionary dynamics in game theory. For (weighted) potential games, the new concept coincides with the fixpoints/equilibria of the dynamics. However, in (variants of) zero-sum games with fully mixed (i.e., interior) Nash equilibria, it covers the whole state space, as the dynamics satisfy specific information theoretic constants of motion. We discuss numerous novel computational, as well as structural, combinatorial questions raised by this chain recurrence conception of games.

A Game of Nontransitive Dice

Intransitive dice tournament is not quasirandom

A counterexample to conjecture "Catch 22" with 3 players, and 5 outcomes: 2 terminal and 3 cyclic

Mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium for a discontinuous symmetric $N$-player game

A Direct Construction of Non-Transitive Dice Sets

Optimal minimax strategy in a dice game

A Central Limit Theorem for intransitive dice

A numbers-on-foreheads game

A Fair Shake: How close can the sum of $n$-sided dice be to a uniform distribution?

The intransitive dice kernel:

Alea Iacta Est: Auctions, Persuasion, Interim Rules, and Dice

Nontransitive Identities: A New Method for Creating Nontransitive Dice

Skill Dominance Analysis of Two(Four) player, Three(Five) dice Variant of the Ludo Game

From Nash Equilibria to Chain Recurrent Sets: An Algorithmic Solution Concept for Game Theory

The Weihrauch degree of finding Nash equilibria in multiplayer games

A Functional Inequality and a New Class of Probabilities in the N-Person Red-and-Black Game

Safe Equilibrium

N-person noncooperative game with infinite strategic space

Statistical physics approaches to Unique Games

A Random-Player Game and Derangement Numbers

Nash, Conley, and Computation: Impossibility and Incompleteness in Game Dynamics