M. Tokieda,K. Hagino
Abstract:Using the phenomenological quantum friction models introduced by Caldirola-Kanai, Kostin, and Albrecht, we study quantum tunneling of a one-dimensional potential in the presence of energy dissipation. To this end, we calculate the tunneling probability using a time-dependent wave packet method. The friction reduces the tunneling probability. We show that the three models provide similar penetrabilities to each other, among which the Caldirola-Kanai model requires the least numerical effort. We also discuss the effect of energy dissipation on quantum tunneling in terms of barrier distributions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the problem of how the probability of quantum tunneling changes in the presence of energy dissipation. Specifically, the authors use three different quantum friction models (Caldirola-Kanai, Kostin, and Albrecht models) to study the phenomenon of quantum tunneling in a one-dimensional barrier. These models simulate energy dissipation by introducing different friction terms, thereby affecting the tunneling probability.
### Main Issues:
1. **Relationship between Quantum Tunneling and Friction**: The paper explores how the probability of quantum tunneling changes in the presence of friction. Friction leads to a reduction in tunneling probability, but the differences between the models require further analysis.
2. **Comparison of Different Models**: The authors compare the performance of the three quantum friction models (Caldirola-Kanai, Kostin, and Albrecht models) in calculating tunneling probability to determine which model is more efficient and accurate in numerical calculations.
3. **Impact of Barrier Distribution**: The paper also discusses the impact of energy dissipation on the barrier distribution during the quantum tunneling process, which is significant for understanding the anomaly of surface diffusion in low-energy heavy-ion fusion reactions.
### Research Background:
- **Low-Energy Heavy-Ion Fusion Reactions**: In low-energy heavy-ion fusion reactions, the excited states of colliding nuclei significantly affect the reaction dynamics, resulting in a much larger fusion cross-section than predicted by simple potential models.
- **Coupled-Channel Method**: To account for the excited states during the reaction process, the coupled-channel method was developed. However, coupled-channel calculations become very difficult when involving a large number of channels.
- **Quantum Friction Models**: To address this issue, various quantum friction models based on the classical concept of friction have been proposed. These models perform well at high incident energies but require quantum mechanical extensions to describe the quantum tunneling process near the Coulomb barrier.
### Research Methods:
- **Time-Dependent Wave Packet Method**: The authors use the time-dependent wave packet method to calculate the tunneling probability, which can better simulate the actual physical process.
- **Numerical Accuracy Testing**: By testing the numerical accuracy of different models under strong and weak friction conditions, the applicability and accuracy of the models were evaluated.
### Main Results:
- **Changes in Tunneling Probability**: Friction significantly reduces the tunneling probability, and as the friction strength increases, the tunneling probability further decreases.
- **Model Comparison**: The three models show similar results in calculating tunneling probability, with the Caldirola-Kanai model being the most efficient in numerical calculations.
- **Barrier Distribution**: The barrier distribution is symmetric and peak-shaped in the absence of friction, while in the presence of friction, part of the intensity shifts to higher energies, making the barrier distribution more structured. This indicates that energy dissipation leads to an increase in the effective barrier height, and this increase is related to the friction strength.
### Conclusion:
- By comparing the three quantum friction models, the paper reveals the impact of friction on the probability of quantum tunneling and provides new insights into understanding the anomaly of surface diffusion in low-energy heavy-ion fusion reactions.
- These results contribute to the development of more accurate quantum mechanical theories for describing dissipative quantum tunneling below the barrier and deep inelastic collisions above the Coulomb barrier.