In-situ identification of various structural features of vanadyl porphyrins in crude oil by high-field (3.4 T) ENDOR spectroscopy combined with DFT calculations

Timur Biktagirov,Marat Gafurov,Georgy Mamin,Irina Gracheva,Andrey Galukhin,Sergei Orlinskii

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.energyfuels.6b02494

2017-01-28

Abstract:Structural characterization of metalloporphyrins in complex systems such as native hydrocarbons is in the focus of scientific and industrial interests since many years. We describe electron-nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) of crude oil from the well without any additional sample treatment (i.e., in the native environment) in the magnetic field of about 3.4 T and temperature of 50 K by applying microwave pulses at 94 GHz (W-band) and radiofrequency pulses at near the proton Larmor frequencies of 144 MHz to probe the paramagnetic vanadyls. By means of density functional theory (DFT) calculations, ENDOR features are explained and ascribed to certain vanadyl porhyrin structural forms known to be present in crude oil.

Materials Science,Other Condensed Matter,Atomic and Molecular Clusters

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: directly identifying vanadyl porphyrins with different structural characteristics in the complex system of crude oil. Specifically, the authors used high - field (3.4 T) ENDOR spectroscopy combined with DFT calculations to study the structure of vanadyl porphyrins in crude oil samples without any additional treatment. The following is a detailed interpretation:

### Research Background and Problems

1. **Importance of Metal Porphyrins**
- The existence of metal porphyrins (such as vanadyl porphyrins) in heavy oil has been known for a long time and has important scientific and industrial significance. They can be used as biomarkers for petroleum formation and provide information about the depositional environment.

2. **Limitations of Existing Methods**
- Traditional separation and characterization methods (such as chromatography, demetalization, etc.) are effective but require pretreatment of samples, which may change the original properties of the samples.
- Techniques such as Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT - ICR MS) can provide detailed structural information but face challenges when dealing with complex crude oils.

3. **Research Objectives**
- This paper aims to directly identify and characterize different structural forms of vanadyl porphyrins in untreated crude oil samples through electron - nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectroscopy combined with density functional theory (DFT) calculations. This method can avoid the influence of sample pretreatment and provide more accurate structural information.

### Methods and Techniques

1. **Experimental Methods**
- Use high - field (3.4 T) ENDOR spectroscopy technology to obtain ENDOR spectra through pulsed EPR measurement and Mims sequence.
- The experimental conditions include a microwave frequency of 94 GHz and a low - temperature environment of 50 K.

2. **Theoretical Calculations**
- Use DFT calculations (using Orca software and PBE0 exchange - correlation functional) to simulate different structural models of vanadyl porphyrins (such as VOEtio, VODPEP, VOBenzo) and calculate their g - tensors and hyperfine coupling parameters.

### Main Findings

1. **ENDOR Spectral Analysis**
- Reproducible hyperfine splitting patterns were observed in two different crude oil samples.
- Combined with DFT calculations, these spectral features were successfully attributed to specific vanadyl porphyrin structural forms (such as VOEtio, VODPEP, VOBenzo).

2. **Structural Diversity**
- The study shows that different types of vanadyl porphyrin molecular structures in crude oil can be identified by analyzing the hyperfine splitting in 1H ENDOR spectra.

### Conclusions

This study shows that 1H ENDOR spectroscopy combined with DFT calculations is an effective non - destructive method that can directly identify and characterize different structural forms of vanadyl porphyrins in complex hydrocarbon mixtures. This method can supplement existing mass spectrometry analysis tools and become part of the standard analysis tools. In addition, due to its high sensitivity and resolution, this method is expected to study the behavior of crude oil during catalytic or heat - treatment processes and provide new insights for the petroleum industry.

### Formula Summary

- **Larmor Frequency**
\[
\nu_{\text{Larmor}}=\frac{\gamma I B_0}{h}
\]
where $\gamma$ is the nuclear magnetic gyromagnetic ratio, $I$ is the nuclear spin quantum number, $B_0$ is the external magnetic field strength, and $h$ is Planck's constant.

- **ENDOR Frequency Caused by Hyperfine Coupling**
\[
\nu_{\text{ENDOR}}=\nu_{\text{Larmor}}\pm\frac{A}{2}\quad\text{or}\quad\nu_{\text{ENDOR}}=\frac{A}{2}\pm\nu_{\text{Larmor}}
\]

- **Estimation of Electron - Nucleus Distance**
\[
a_{\text{ENDOR}}\propto\frac{g g(I)(1 - 3\cos^2\theta)}{r^3}
\]
where $g$ and $g(I)$ are the g - factors of electron and nuclear spins respectively, and $\theta$ is the electron - nucleus.