Abstract:Globally, agriculture sector is the significant source of greenhouse gases (GHGs) emissions into the atmosphere. To achieve the goal of limiting or mitigating these emissions, a rigorous abatement strategy with an additional focus on improving crop productivity is now imperative. Replacing traditional agriculture with soil conservation-based farming can have numerous ecological benefits. However, most assessments only consider improvements in soil properties and crop productivity, and often preclude the quantitative impact analysis on GHGs emissions. Here, we conducted a meta-analysis to evaluate crop productivity (i.e., biomass, grain, total yield) and GHGs emissions (i.e., CO2, N2O, CH4) for three major soil conservation practices i.e., no-tillage, manures, and biochar. We also examined the yield potential of three major cereal crops (i.e., wheat, rice, maize) and their significance in mitigating GHGs emissions. None of the manures were able to reduce GHGs emissions, with poultry manure being the largest contributor to all GHGs emissions. However, pig-manure had the greatest impact on crop yield while emitting the least CO2 emissions Use of biochar showed a strong coupling effect between reduction of GHGs (i.e., CH4 by -37%; N2O by -25%; CO2 by -5%) and the increase in crop productivity. In contrast, no-tillage resulted in higher GHGs emissions with only a marginal increase in grain yield. Depending on crop type, all cereal crops showed varied degrees of GHGs mitigation under biochar application, with wheat responding most strongly due to the additional yield increment. The addition of biochar significantly reduced CO2 and N2O emissions under both rainfed and irrigated conditions, although CH4 reductions were identical in both agroecosystems. Interestingly, the use of biochar resulted in a greater yield benefit in rainfed than in irrigated agriculture. Despite significant GHGs emissions, manure application contributed to higher crop yields, regardless of soil type or agroecosystem. Moreover, no-tillage showed a significant reduction in CH4 and N2O emissions under rainfed and irrigated conditions. Notably , biochar application in coarse while no-till in fine textured soils contributed to N2O mitigation. Most importantly, effectiveness of no-tillage as a countermeasure to GHGs emissions while providing yield benefits is inconsistent. Overall, the decision to use farm manures should be reconsidered due to higher GHGs emissions. We conclude that the use of biochar could be an ideal way to reduce GHGs emissions. However, further understanding of the underlying mechanisms and processes affecting GHGs emissions is needed to better understand the feedback effects in conservation agriculture.

Does no-till crop management mitigate gaseous emissions and reduce yield disparities: An empirical US-China evaluation

No tillage decreases GHG emissions with no crop yield tradeoff at the global scale

Greenhouse gas emissions from the wheat-maize cropping system under different tillage and crop residue management practices in the North China Plain

Effects of no-tillage on greenhouse gas emissions in maize fields in a semi-humid temperate climate region

Responses of Soil Greenhouse Gas Emissions to No-Tillage: A Global Meta-Analysis

Different Responses of Agroecosystem Greenhouse Gas Emissions to Tillage Practices in a Chinese Wheat–maize Cropping System

Mitigation Potential of Greenhouse Gases under Different Scenarios of Optimal Synthetic Nitrogen Application Rate for Grain Crops in China

Conservative strip tillage system in maize maintains high yield and mitigates GHG emissions but promotes N2O emissions

Reducing N2O and NO emissions while sustaining crop productivity in a Chinese vegetable-cereal double cropping system

Effects of conservation tillage strategies on soil physicochemical indicators and N2O emission under spring wheat monocropping system conditions

Greenhouse gas emissions in a spring wheat–field pea sequence under different tillage practices in semi-arid Northwest China

Greenhouse gas emissions from the growing season are regulated by precipitation events in conservation tillage farmland ecosystems of Northeast China

Trade-offs between high yields and soil CO<sub>2</sub> emissions in semi-humid maize cropland in northern China

Do soil conservation practices exceed their relevance as a countermeasure to greenhouse gases emissions and increase crop productivity in agriculture?

Impact of agronomy practices on the effects of reduced tillage systems on CH4 and N2O emissions from agricultural fields: A global meta-analysis

Effects of tillage and cropping sequences on crop production and environmental benefits in the North China Plain

Effects of long-term no tillage and straw return on greenhouse gas emissions and crop yields from a rice-wheat system in central China

Conservation tillage: a way to improve yield and soil properties and decrease global warming potential in spring wheat agroecosystems

Long‐term continuous cropping reduces greenhouse gas emissions while sustaining crop yields

Influence of Straw Mulch and No-Tillage on Soil Respiration, Its Components and Economic Benefit in a Chinese Wheat–maize Cropping System

Soil CO2 Emission Reduction with No-Tillage and Medium Nitrogen Fertilizer Applications in Semi-Humid Maize Cropland in North China Plain