Sedimentary brGDGTs in China: An overview of modern observations and proposed land Holocene paleotemperature records

Tianyan Lin,Zhiguo Rao,Yaoyao Zeng,Yunxia Li,Lin Zhao,Lidan Liu,Xiong Xiao,Cicheng Zhang,Zhongwei Shen,Jiantao Cao,Guodong Jia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.earscirev.2024.104694
IF: 12.038
2024-01-23
Earth-Science Reviews
Abstract:Results from globally distributed surface soils and surface lake and peat sediments indicate that brGDGTs (branched glycerol dialkyl glycerol tetraethers), derived from bacteria, have the potential to reconstruct the history of land temperature changes. Studies of brGDGTs in China have been conducted on a large spatial scale, but the proposed brGDGTs-based land Holocene temperature records show contrasting temporal patterns. In this study, we used modern observations of brGDGTs combined with the analysis of other modern climate data and paleoclimate records to re-evaluate the proposed brGDGTs-based land Holocene paleotemperature records from China. Our findings indicate that: (i) the proposed brGDGTs-based Holocene paleotemperature records from Chinese loess deposits are more possibly indicative of humidity changes. (ii) brGDGTs in lake sediments are significantly influenced not only by air/water temperatures but also by water depth, salinity, seasonal freezing and so on, and therefore the paleoclimatic significance of individual brGDGTs-based Holocene climate records from Chinese lakes needs to be carefully evaluated. The long-term Holocene warming trend indicated by brGDGTs-based records from most shallow, freshwater Chinese lakes without surface freezing are relatively dependable. (iii) Given modern observations of brGDGTs are rarely conducted in peatlands in Northeast China, we therefore suggest the long-term Holocene warming trend indicated by brGDGTs-based records from the 5 peatlands along the transect from Southeast to Northwest China is more reliable than the long-term Holocene cooling trend indicated by brGDGTs-based records from the two peatlands in Northeast China. Therefore, currently, we are roughly incline to believe the long-term Holocene warming trend in some of the Chinese lake and peat brGDGTs-based records. As our knowledge of the environmental significance of brGDGTs continues to increase, we anticipate that they can make a substantial contribution to resolving the "Holocene temperature conundrum".
geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the potential and limitations of branched glycerol dialkyl glycerol tetraethers (brGDGTs) as indicators for reconstructing Holocene terrestrial temperature changes in different regions of China (loess, lakes, and peatlands). Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following issues: 1. **Application of brGDGTs in loess**: By analyzing brGDGTs data from Chinese loess profiles, the study evaluates their effectiveness as indicators for Holocene temperature reconstruction. The research finds that brGDGTs in Chinese loess sediments more reflect humidity changes rather than temperature changes. 2. **brGDGTs in lake sediments**: The study investigates whether brGDGTs in lake sediments can reliably reflect Holocene climate changes. The research points out that brGDGTs in lake sediments are influenced not only by air and water temperatures but also by factors such as water depth, salinity, and seasonal freezing, thus requiring careful assessment of their paleoclimatic significance. 3. **brGDGTs in peatlands**: The study evaluates the reliability of brGDGTs records in peatlands of northeastern China. The research suggests that peatland records from southeast to northwest show a more reliable Holocene warming trend, while two peatland records from northeastern China show a cooling trend, indicating lower reliability. Overall, the paper aims to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the application of brGDGTs in different environments in China, with the goal of better understanding their potential and limitations in addressing the "Holocene temperature puzzle."