Abstract:Current agricultural practices are increasingly considered to be unsustainable, causing serious threats to the environment. To meet international and European sustainability goals, the transition to sustainable agriculture is pivotal and ways to achieve it are currently under discussion. Conventional agricultural systems are typically highly productive, ensuring high yields for feeding a growing global population, but with significant environmental costs. Contrarily, organic agriculture is perceived as a sustainable farming option, however, is often criticized for achieving lower yields, so that when this factor is taken into account, its advantages are often questioned. To compare the environmental performance of different cropping system, life cycle assessment (LCA) has been increasingly applied over time. The present work aims at systematically reviewing LCA studies that consistently assess and compare the environmental impacts of organic and conventional crop systems, enabling the understanding of the environmental performance of organic and conventional management systems, including a broad spectrum of impacts (15 environmental indicators in total). The systematic review, complemented with a meta-analysis, resulted in the selection and analysis of 77 pairwise comparative LCA studies. These perform a comparison between the two cultivation management systems (i.e. organic and conventional) of a specific crop or group of crops, cultivated under similar pedoclimatic conditions in both systems, and show consistency in the main LCA methodological choices. Independently from the functional unit adopted (mass or land-based) and despite the lower yields, organic systems show overall a better environmental performance than conventional ones. These results are valid for the majority of the impacts assessed (climate change, ozone depletion, ecotoxicity, human toxicity, acidification, eutrophication, use of resources, water, and energy). Certain crop classes systematically show lower impacts when organically cultivated, although exception exists within the same class (e.g. overall trend valid for fruit but not for apples). Fertilisation resulted to be the cultivation process responsible for most of the impacts in conventional systems, playing a key role also in organic systems together with activities linked to machinery and field operations. The heterogeneity of modelling approaches encountered makes the comparison of cropping systems difficult and the definition of trends challenging. Modelling differences were found regarding the choice of functional unit and inventory models to estimate emissions, the inclusion or exclusion of certain processes or flows in the inventory, and the selection and modelling of impact categories. In addition, key aspects such as soil quality, biodiversity and water use are still poorly investigated.

Life cycle assessment of conventional and organic Arabica coffees: from farm to pack

Life cycle assessment synthesis of the carbon footprint of Arabica coffee: Case study of Brazil and Vietnam conventional and sustainable coffee production and export to the United Kingdom

Unravelling life cycle impacts of coffee: Why do results differ so much among studies?

A comparison of life cycle assessment (LCA) of Andungsari Arabica coffee processing technologies towards lower environmental impact.

Comparative life cycle assessment for conventional and organic coffee cultivation in Vietnam

A Life Cycle Assessment of Organic and Chemical Fertilizers for Coffee Production to Evaluate Sustainability toward the Energy–Environment–Economic Nexus in Indonesia

Consumers’ values and behaviour in the Brazilian coffee-in-capsules market: promoting circular economy

Life Cycle Assessment of Gayo Arabica Coffee Green Bean at Aceh Province

The innovation and local culture in the production of specialty coffee in Short Food Supply Chains and their impacts on environmental sustainability

Dynamics of Carbon and Soil Enzyme Activities under Arabica Coffee Intercropped with Brachiaria decumbens in the Brazilian Cerrado

Impacts of Brazilian Green Coffee Production and Its Logistical Corridors on the International Coffee Market

Life Cycle Assessment of the Sugarcane Supply Chain in the Brazilian Midwest Region

Effects of geographical origin and post-harvesting processing on the bioactive compounds and sensory quality of Brazilian specialty coffee beans

Life Cycle Assessment for Soybean Supply Chain: A Case Study of State of Pará, Brazil

SELEÇÃO DE MATERIAIS NO DESIGN DE EMBALAGENS: FATORES INFLUENCIADORES NO MERCADO BRASILEIRO DE CAFÉ

Transformation of coffee-growing landscapes across Latin America. A review

Predicting best planting location and coffee cup quality from chemical parameters: An evaluation of raw Arabica coffee beans from São Paulo over two harvests

Carbon footprints and carbon stocks reveal climate-friendly coffee production

Unveiling the social performance of selected agri-food chains in Costa Rica: the case of green coffee, raw milk and leafy vegetables

COFFEE SILVERSKIN AND EXPIRED COFFEE POWDER USED AS ORGANIC FERTILIZERS

Comparison of organic and conventional cropping systems: A systematic review of life cycle assessment studies