Abstract:Completely randomized experiments have been the gold standard for drawing causal inference because they can balance all potential confounding on average. However, they may suffer from unbalanced covariates for realized treatment assignments. Rerandomization, a design that rerandomizes the treatment assignment until a prespecified covariate balance criterion is met, has recently got attention due to its easy implementation, improved covariate balance and more efficient inference. Researchers have then suggested to use the treatment assignments that minimize the covariate imbalance, namely the optimally balanced design. This has caused again the long-time controversy between two philosophies for designing experiments: randomization versus optimal and thus almost deterministic designs. Existing literature argued that rerandomization with overly balanced observed covariates can lead to highly imbalanced unobserved covariates, making it vulnerable to model misspecification. On the contrary, rerandomization with properly balanced covariates can provide robust inference for treatment effects while sacrificing some efficiency compared to the ideally optimal design. In this paper, we show it is possible that, by making the covariate imbalance diminishing at a proper rate as the sample size increases, rerandomization can achieve its ideally optimal precision that one can expect with perfectly balanced covariates, while still maintaining its robustness. We further investigate conditions on the number of covariates for achieving the desired optimality. Our results rely on a more delicate asymptotic analysis for rerandomization. The derived theory for rerandomization provides a deeper understanding of its large-sample property and can better guide its practical implementation. Furthermore, it also helps reconcile the controversy between randomized and optimal designs in an asymptotic sense.

Nearly Random Designs with Greatly Improved Balance

Better Experimental Design by Hybridizing Binary Matching with Imbalance Optimization

Rerandomization with Diminishing Covariate Imbalance and Diverging Number of Covariates

Efficient Balanced Treatment Assignments for Experimentation

Rerandomization to Balance Tiers of Covariates

Improving Covariate Balance in 2^K Factorial Designs via Rerandomization

Efficient Randomized-Adaptive Designs

The Optimality of Blocking Designs in Equally and Unequally Allocated Randomized Experiments with General Response

Improving Covariate Balance in 2K Factorial Designs Via Rerandomization with an Application to a New York City Department of Education High School Study

Finely Stratified Rerandomization Designs

On the Optimality of Randomization in Experimental Design: How to Randomize for Minimax Variance and Design-Based Inference

Optimal allocation of sample size for randomization-based inference from 2 K factorial designs

Optimal Stratification of Survey Experiments

Balancing Covariates in Randomized Experiments with the Gram-Schmidt Walk Design

Design-based theory for cluster rerandomization

A Bayesian Response-Adaptive Covariate-Balanced Randomization Design with Application to A Leukemia Clinical Trial

Inspection-Guided Randomization: A Flexible and Transparent Restricted Randomization Framework for Better Experimental Design

Optimal refinement of strata to balance covariates

On Optimal Rerandomization Designs

Steady‐state statistical properties and implementation of randomization designs with maximum tolerated imbalance restriction for two‐arm equal allocation clinical trials

Randomization Tests that Condition on Non-Categorical Covariate Balance