Abstract:Organometallic clusters based on transition metal atoms are interesting because possible applications in spintronics and quantum information. In addition to the enhanced magnetism at the nanoscale, the organic ligands may provide a natural shield again unwanted magnetic interactions with the matrices required for applications. Here we show that the organic ligands may lead to non-collinear magnetic order as well as the expected quenching of the magnetic moments. We use different density functional theory (DFT) methods to study the experimentally relevant three cobalt atoms surrounded by benzene rings (Co$_3$Bz$_3$). We found that the benzene rings induce a ground state with non-collinear magnetization, with the magnetic moments localized on the cobalt centers and lying on the plane formed by the three cobalt atoms. We further analyze the magnetism of such a cluster using an anisotropic Heisenberg model where the involved parameters are obtained by a comparison with the DFT results. These results may also explain the recent observation of null magnetic moment of Co$_3$Bz$_3^+$. Moreover, we propose an additional experimental verification based on electron paramagnetic resonance.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the non - collinear magnetic phenomena in small - molecule magnetic cobalt - benzene (Co₃Bz₃) clusters. Specifically, the researchers are concerned with: 1. **The influence of organic ligands on magnetism**: By introducing organic ligands (such as benzene rings), explore how these ligands affect the magnetic arrangement of cobalt atoms. In particular, it has been found that the presence of benzene rings can induce non - collinear magnetic order, rather than just the expected magnetic moment quenching. 2. **Explaining the experimentally observed zero - magnetic - moment phenomenon**: Recent studies have shown that the ionized Co₃Bz₃⁺ clusters have no magnetic response at low temperatures. The authors hope to explain this phenomenon through theoretical calculations and propose further experimental verification methods. 3. **Exploring the magnetic mechanism**: Use different density functional theory (DFT) methods to study the magnetic behavior of Co₃Bz₃ clusters composed of three cobalt atoms and three benzene rings, and reveal their magnetic coupling mechanisms and the interactions with benzene rings. ### Specific problems - **The origin of non - collinear magnetism**: Through DFT calculations, the researchers found that the presence of benzene rings makes the ground state of the Co₃Bz₃ cluster exhibit non - collinear magnetic order, and the magnetic moment is located on the plane formed by the three cobalt atoms. - **The reason for magnetic moment quenching**: By comparing the energies of different magnetic configurations, the researchers found that the ground - state energy of the non - collinear magnetic order is about 200 meV lower than that of other configurations, which may be one of the reasons for the magnetic moment quenching. - **Magnetic anisotropy and spin coupling**: Based on the DFT results, the researchers proposed a Heisenberg model including magnetic anisotropy and spin coupling to describe the low - energy magnetic configurations of the Co₃Bz₃ cluster. The model parameters were obtained by comparing with the DFT results, which further explained the phenomena observed in the experiments. ### Experimental verification To further verify the theoretical results, the researchers suggest using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) technology to distinguish between collinear and non - collinear magnetic configurations and to reveal the magnetic anisotropy of the clusters through the angular dependence of the EPR signals. In summary, this paper aims to deeply understand the influence of organic ligands on the magnetism of transition - metal clusters through theoretical calculations and model construction, and to explain the special magnetic phenomena observed in the experiments.

Non-Collinearity in Small Magnetic Cobalt-Benzene Molecules

CoX2Y4: A Family of Two-Dimensional Magnets with Versatile Magnetic Order

Electronic-Structure Calculations of Cobalt Clusters

Entangled Electrons Drive a Non-superexchange Mechanism in a Cobalt Quinoid Dimer Complex

Molecule‐Induced Huge D‐p Overlap Enhances Superexchange Interaction for Room‐Temperature In‐Plane Magnetism and Giant Magneto Band‐Structure Effect in Ferromagnetic Clusterphene

Magnetic properties of icosahedral copper-coated cobalt clusters

Noncollinear magnetism calculation of iron clusters with spin-orbit coupling

Precursor molecules for cobalt(II) single molecule magnets – Synthesis and magnetic properties

The distinguishing effect of the magnetic states of cobalt on the performance of single-molecule magnet behaviors in a closely related CoIIIDyIII and CoIIDyIII complexes

Magnetic Properties Of Cobalt Clusters Embedded In A Copper Matrix

Magnetism Enhanced Layer-Like Structure of Small Cobalt Clusters

An azido-bridged disc-like heptanuclear cobalt(II) cluster: towards a single-molecule magnet.

Field-induced Slow Magnetic Relaxation Behaviours in Binuclear Cobalt(ii) Metallocycles and Exchange-Coupled Clusters.

Orbital‐dependent Magnetic Properties of Molecular Cluster Containing High‐spin Co(II) Ions

From mononuclear to two-dimensional cobalt(II) complexes based on a mixed benzimidazole–dicarboxylate strategy: syntheses, structures, and magnetic properties

Spin-orbit entangled moments and magnetic exchange interactions in cobalt-based honeycomb magnets BaCo$_2$($X$O$_4$)$_2$ ($X$ = P, As, Sb)

Electronic structure of mononuclear and radical-bridged dinuclear cobalt(II) single-molecule magnets

Magnetic properties of {M$_4$} coordination clusters with different magnetic cores (M=Co, Mn)

Novel Structures of Co-Cu Bimetallic Clusters and Their Magnetic Properties

Field-induced slow magnetic relaxation behaviours in binuclear cobalt(II) metallocycle and exchange-coupled cluster

Spin Interaction and Magnetism in Cobaltate Kitaev Candidate Materials: an Ab Initio and Model Hamiltonian Approach