Curvature driven motion of soap cells in toroidal Hele-Shaw cells

A. Mughal,S. J. Cox,G. E. Schroeder-Turk

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1610.09239

2017-04-04

Abstract:We investigate the equilibrium properties of a single area-minimising bubble trapped between two narrowly-separated parallel curved plates. We begin with the simple case of a a bubble trapped between concentric spherical plates. We develop a model that shows that the surface tension energy of the bubble is lower when confined between spherical plates as compared to a bubble trapped between flat plates. We confirm our findings by comparing against Surface Evolver simulations. Next, we derive a simple model for a bubble between arbitrarily curved parallel plates. The energy is found to be higher when the local Gaussian curvature of the plates is negative and lower when the curvature is positive. To check the validity of the the model we consider a bubble trapped between concentric tori. In the toroidal case we find that the sensitivity of the bubble's energy to the local curvature acts as a geometric potential capable of driving bubbles from regions with negative to positive curvature.

Soft Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper investigates the equilibrium properties of a single area-minimizing bubble between two closely spaced parallel curved plates. Specifically, the authors focus on the surface energy changes of the bubble under different curvature conditions.

#### Main Issues:
1. **Energy differences of bubbles between curved plates of different shapes**: The authors first study the energy of a bubble between concentric spherical plates and find that its surface energy is lower than that between flat plates.
2. **Energy model of bubbles between arbitrary curved plates**: The authors derive a simple model to describe the energy of a bubble between arbitrary curved plates. The results show that when the local Gaussian curvature is positive, the bubble's energy is lower; when the curvature is negative, the energy is higher.
3. **Effect of geometric potential**: By considering the behavior of bubbles between toroidal plates, the authors find that the bubble's sensitivity to local curvature can form a geometric potential that drives the bubble from regions of negative curvature to regions of positive curvature.

### Research Background:
- **Isoperimetric problem**: Mathematicians and physicists have long been concerned with the problem of enclosing a given volume with the smallest surface area. Due to the effect of surface tension, the free energy of soap bubbles directly depends on their surface area, making soap bubbles a rich field for studying the isoperimetric problem.
- **Hele-Shaw cell**: In two dimensions, the most efficient way to enclose equal area units is a honeycomb structure. In the laboratory, this structure can be approximated by sandwiching a layer of equally sized bubbles between two closely spaced parallel glass plates. This structure is also widely used in studying the structure and dynamics of disordered polydisperse quasi-2D foams.

### Research Methods:
- **Model derivation**: The authors first derive an energy model for bubbles between concentric spherical plates and validate the model's accuracy through Surface Evolver simulations.
- **Extension to arbitrary surfaces**: The authors then further derive an energy model for bubbles between arbitrary curved plates, with particular consideration of the behavior of bubbles between toroidal plates.
- **Numerical simulation**: Numerical simulations using Surface Evolver software are conducted to validate the theoretical model's predictions.

### Conclusions:
- **Impact of geometric potential**: The energy differences of bubbles under different curvature conditions can be explained as a geometric potential, which can drive bubbles from regions of negative curvature to regions of positive curvature.
- **Application prospects**: This result not only helps to understand the behavior of single bubbles but may also be applied to fields such as microfluidics, cell adhesion and movement on curved surfaces, and bubble movement in porous media.

### Summary:
Through theoretical models and numerical simulations, this paper systematically studies the energy changes of bubbles under different curvature conditions and the underlying geometric potential effect, providing a new perspective for understanding the behavior of bubbles in complex geometric environments.