Abstract:Background: Previous research has shown the feasibility of using machine learning models trained on social media data from a single platform (eg, Facebook or Twitter) to distinguish individuals either with a diagnosis of mental illness or experiencing an adverse outcome from healthy controls. However, the performance of such models on data from novel social media platforms unseen in the training data (eg, Instagram and TikTok) has not been investigated in previous literature. Objective: Our study examined the feasibility of building machine learning classifiers that can effectively predict an upcoming psychiatric hospitalization given social media data from platforms unseen in the classifiers' training data despite the preliminary evidence on identity fragmentation on the investigated social media platforms. Methods: Windowed timeline data of patients with a diagnosis of schizophrenia spectrum disorder before a known hospitalization event and healthy controls were gathered from 3 platforms: Facebook (254/268, 94.8% of participants), Twitter (51/268, 19% of participants), and Instagram (134/268, 50% of participants). We then used a 3 × 3 combinatorial binary classification design to train machine learning classifiers and evaluate their performance on testing data from all available platforms. We further compared results from models in intraplatform experiments (ie, training and testing data belonging to the same platform) to those from models in interplatform experiments (ie, training and testing data belonging to different platforms). Finally, we used Shapley Additive Explanation values to extract the top predictive features to explain and compare the underlying constructs that predict hospitalization on each platform. Results: We found that models in intraplatform experiments on average achieved an F 1 -score of 0.72 (SD 0.07) in predicting a psychiatric hospitalization because of schizophrenia spectrum disorder, which is 68% higher than the average of models in interplatform experiments at an F 1 -score of 0.428 (SD 0.11). When investigating the key drivers for divergence in construct validities between models, an analysis of top features for the intraplatform models showed both low predictive feature overlap between the platforms and low pairwise rank correlation (<0.1) between the platforms' top feature rankings. Furthermore, low average cosine similarity of data between platforms within participants in comparison with the same measurement on data within platforms between participants points to evidence of identity fragmentation of participants between platforms. Conclusions: We demonstrated that models built on one platform's data to predict critical mental health treatment outcomes such as hospitalization do not generalize to another platform. In our case, this is because different social media platforms consistently reflect different segments of participants' identities. With the changing ecosystem of social media use among different demographic groups and as web-based identities continue to become fragmented across platforms, further research on holistic approaches to harnessing these diverse data sources is required.

Instagram photos reveal predictive markers of depression

Depression Prediction using Machine Learning Algorithms

What Twitter Profile and Posted Images Reveal About Depression and Anxiety

Dynamic Facial Features in Positive-Emotional Speech for Identification of Depressive Tendencies

Social Media Images Can Predict Suicide Risk Using Interpretable Large Language-Vision Models

A Picture May Be Worth a Thousand Lives: An Interpretable Artificial Intelligence Strategy for Predictions of Suicide Risk from Social Media Images

Detecting and Measuring Depression on Social Media Using a Machine Learning Approach: Systematic Review

Multimodal time-aware attention networks for depression detection

Machine learning and natural language processing to assess the emotional impact of influencers’ mental health content on Instagram

Machine Learning for Depression Detection on Web and Social Media

Subphenotyping Depression Using Machine Learning and Electronic Health Records

See and Read: Detecting Depression Symptoms in Higher Education Students Using Multimodal Social Media Data

MoodCapture: Depression Detection Using In-the-Wild Smartphone Images

Systematic Review: Text Processing Algorithms in Machine Learning and Deep Learning for Mental Health Detection on Social Media

Analysis of Deep Learning Techniques for Early Detection of Depression on Social Media Network - A Comparative Study

Detecting and Measuring Depression on Social Media by Machine Learning Approach: a Review (Preprint)

Faces of the Mind: Unveiling Mental Health States Through Facial Expressions in 11,427 Adolescents

Predicting dimensions of depression from smartphone data

Predicting mental health using social media: A roadmap for future development

A machine learning approach predicts future risk to suicidal ideation from social media data

Cross-Platform Detection of Psychiatric Hospitalization via Social Media Data: Comparison Study